Re: [PATCH v3] kdb: Replace deprecated strcpy() with strscpy() and memcpy()

[Thorsten Blum]

On 15. Aug 2025, at 13:40, Daniel Thompson wrote:
> On Fri, Aug 15, 2025 at 01:28:01PM +0200, Thorsten Blum wrote:
>> Hi Daniel,
>> 
>>> On 15. Aug 2025, at 10:57, Daniel Thompson wrote:
>>> Sorry but a strscpy() where the length of the destination buffer has
>>> been calculated from the source string is way too much of a red flag
>>> for me.
>>> 
>>> Put another way if there are "no functional changes intended" then there
>>> cannot possibly be any security benefit from replacing the "unsafe"
>>> strcpy() with the "safe" strscpy(). Likewise abusing the destination
>>> length argument to truncate a string makes the code shorter but *not*
>>> clearer because it's too easy to misread.
>> 
>> Deliberately truncating the source using strscpy() is a valid use case.
>> strscpy() allows the size argument to be smaller than the destination
>> buffer, so this is an intended use of the size argument, not an abuse.
> 
> Sorry, I didn't phrase that especially well. I regard the abuse to be
> deriving the length of the destination buffer exclusively from the
> state of the source buffer.
> 
> As mentioned, it would be much cleaner to eliminate the string copy entirely
> than to translate it into something so similar to the original strcpy().

Something like this?

char *kdb_strdup_dequote(const char *str, gfp_t type)
{
        size_t len = strlen(str);
        char *s;

        if (str[0] == '"') {
                /* skip leading quote */
                len--;
                str++;

                if (len > 0 && str[len - 1] == '"')
                        len--; /* skip trailing quote */
       }

        len++; /* add space for NUL terminator */

        s = kmalloc(len, type);
        if (!s)
                return NULL;
        strscpy(s, str, len);
        return s;
}

This should probably be a separate patch, right?

Thanks,
Thorsten