Le 16/01/2017 à 18:36, Jan Krieger a écrit : > Dear all! > > I'm currently trying to rework the chokes/Inductors in the kicad-lib, as I > already did for > resistors, capacitors and diodes. This will include three major steps: > > 1. rename all inductors/chokes so their names start with L_ so it is easier > to match them > 2. create clean and KLC-conforming footprints (using scripts) > 3. create (semi-scripted) 3D models for all new footprints > > This went through quite smoothely for caps and resistors, but with the > inductors I'm facing problems > with the structure of the libs. Currently we have a mess: > - Choke_Axial_ThroughHole.pretty > - Choke_Common-Mode_Wurth.pretty > - Choke_Radial_ThroughHole.pretty > - Choke_SMD.pretty > - Choke_Toroid_ThroughHole.pretty > - Inductors.pretty > - Inductors_NEOSID.pretty > - Transformers_CHK > - Transformers_SMPS_ThroughHole > > I would really like to clean that up ... which would (IMHO leave with this > list of repos (and delete > all above repos!): > - Inductors_ThroughHole.pretty > - Inductors_SMD.pretty > - Transformers_ThroughHole.pretty > - Transformers_SMD.pretty > > ... just maybe it would make sense to also have the common-mode chokes in > separate repos, but I'm > not so sure this is really required! > > Yes the libs would then be quite full (few 100 maybe in the case of > Inductors_*, but it is then > easier to enforce a naming-scheme and have people know where to submit new > components. > > What do you think? How can we go about this (generate libs, delete the old > ones, or do we simply > rename them "_deprecated" or something? > > Best, > JAN > > PS: Since I'm currently home with not much to do (still this week ... a flu > got me), I could work on > this if we get the repos up and running ... + I already have nice new > footprints + 3D models ... >
Hi Alls, Generally speaking, be *extremely careful* when deleting/renaming existing libraries. Because when doing that, you are breaking the current kicad projects compatibility, which store the library names at least in project config. In the early times of the repos, it was possible. It is now no more acceptable. To break a compatibility, you need to have a *very good reason*. As long is it possible, you have to live with the fact changes in kicad libraries must not break the compatibility. In short: you have to live with the mess. This is my opinion. -- Jean-Pierre CHARRAS -- Mailing list: https://launchpad.net/~kicad-lib-committers Post to : kicad-lib-committers@lists.launchpad.net Unsubscribe : https://launchpad.net/~kicad-lib-committers More help : https://help.launchpad.net/ListHelp
