Hi

I have two questions about this blog post on multi-signers: 
https://en.blog.nic.cz/2025/05/07/knot-dns-in-a-complex-dnssec-topology/

First, the blog post shows auto-increment SOA serial mode for the zone files 
in-line with the docs example:

```
zonefile-sync: -1zonefile-load: difference-no-serial
journal-content: all
```

This would work fine for me in general, I don't mind zone files being the 
"source of truth".

But the docs has a note "This mode is not suitable if the zone can be modified 
externally (e.g. DDNS, knotc)."


Do I understand correctly that this is because any dynamic changes to the zone 
get wiped on reboot ?  So, for example, if the only external DDNS modification 
in my environment is DNS-01 for cert issuance, it won't cause me a problem, 
because those are ephemeral by nature anyway ?


This then raises the second question, how would I deal with catlog zones with 
this concept of multi-signers ? Or are catlog zones too much trouble in a 
multi-signer environment ?


Thank you
--

Reply via email to