*Synopsis*: VSC 5.2.13 POSIX.cmd/cmp tests fail on OpenSolaris (snv_127)
CR 6904808/solaris_nevada changed on Mar 26 2010 by <User 1-5Q-3780>
=== Field ============ === New Value ============= === Old Value =============
SR 1-597322520
Functionality Secondary
Hardware generic
Impact Limited
Operating System osol_2010.03
Product Name solaris
Product Release osol_2010.03
Severity 4
====================== =========================== ===========================
*Change Request ID*: 6904808/solaris_nevada
*Synopsis*: VSC 5.2.13 POSIX.cmd/cmp tests fail on OpenSolaris (snv_127)
Product: solaris
Category: shell
Subcategory: korn93
Type: Defect
Subtype: Functionality
Status: 1-Dispatched
Substatus:
Priority: 4-Low
Introduced In Release:
Introduced In Build:
Responsible Engineer:
Keywords: OpenSolaris, VSC, cmp, stdsosol0906
=== *Description* ============================================================
Running VSC 5.2.13 on OpenSolaris based on snv_127 showed some failures for
/POSIX.cmd/cmp tests assertions 14, 15 and 18. The error message written to the
journal file is identical for all 3 assertions. An example is shown below:
520|70 15 25221 1 1|Assertion #15 (A): Verify output of ga66.
520|70 15 25221 2 1|Expected exit code = 0; Received 1
220|70 15 1 22:41:36|FAIL
410|70 15 1 22:41:36|IC End
*** (#1 of 1): 2009-11-25 15:30:52 GMT+00:00 <User 1-5Q-6084>
=== *Public Comments* ========================================================
Comments from OpenSolaris ksh93 project lead Roland Mainz (<email address
omitted>):
> 520|70 15 25221 1 1|Assertion #15 (A): Verify output of ga66.
> 520|70 15 25221 2 1|Expected exit code = 0; Received 1
> 220|70 15 1 22:41:36|FAIL
> 410|70 15 1 22:41:36|IC End
This is not an error in AST "cmp", this is IMO a bug in the test suite.
Glenn Fowler from AT&T explained the issue in one of his postings:
-- snip --
the VSC tests for the other assertions [Glenn refers to the assertions
reported in CR #6904808] are flawed. They assume that cmp must always
read the input files and thus touch the st_atime but in the case where
both files are the same cmp can exit 0 after just a stat() of each file
it produces the correct result but does not cause any stat() field of
the input files to change.
-- snip --
BTW: GNU "cmp" and BSD "cmp" use the same optimisation (and therefore
will not change the access timestamp and therefore fail these tests,
too).
AFAIK this bug should be closed and a bug report against VSC needs to be
filed.
*** (#1 of 1): 2010-01-12 05:08:19 GMT+00:00 <User 1-5Q-1267>
=== *Workaround* =============================================================
=== *Additional Details* =====================================================
Targeted Release: solaris_nevada
Commit To Fix In Build:
Fixed In Build:
Integrated In Build:
Verified In Build:
See Also:
Duplicate of:
Hooks:
Hook1:
Hook2:
Hook3:
Hook4:
Hook5:
Hook6:
Program Management:
Root Cause:
Fix Affects Documentation: No
Fix Affects Localization: No
=== *History* ================================================================
Date Submitted: 2009-11-25 15:30:51 GMT+00:00
Submitted By: <User 1-5Q-6084>
Status Changed Date Updated Updated By
=== *Service Request* ========================================================
Impact: Limited
Functionality: Secondary
Severity: 4
Product Name: solaris
Product Release: osol_2009.06
Product Build:
Operating System: osol_2009.06
Hardware: x86
Submitted Date: 2009-11-25 15:30:52 GMT+00:00
=== *Service Request* ========================================================
Impact: Limited
Functionality: Secondary
Severity: 4
Product Name: solaris
Product Release: osol_2010.03
Product Build:
Operating System: osol_2010.03
Hardware: generic
Submitted Date: 2010-03-26 17:48:08 GMT+00:00
=== *Multiple Release (MR) Cluster* - 6904808 ================================
ID: +6904808/solaris_nevada
SubCR Number: 6904808
Targeted Release: solaris_nevada
=== *SubCR* ==================================================================
ID: 6904808/solaris_10u9
Status: 1-Dispatched
Substatus:
Priority: 4-Low
Responsible Engineer:
SubCR Number: 2190837
Targeted Release: solaris_10u9
Commit To Fix In Build:
Fixed In Build:
Integrated In Build:
Verified In Build:
Hook1:
Hook2:
Program Management:
