We all know how wordy Tamara can be <g>; I prefer to write as little as possible.
Yeah, well, so do I, actually :) My early patterns were lengthy, because I didn't know what a person might be *expected* to know, and because I was still re-inventing the wheel twice daily... <g> Now, the instructions are lengthy because, half of the time, I'm leaving the confines of tradition on purpose, and don't feel it's fair *not* to document it. But... When you break out of the box in a book, you can do it *once*, and make it apply to all the following patterns; when you do a single pattern, you have to state the "ground rules" *every time*, adding to the overall length.
Take this year's IOLI entry. 10 (different; some are mirrored, for a total of 17) elements, *mostly* Milanese. Where the braid had been documented before, I refer the lacemaker to the book where it can be found; it is, afterall, a *pattern*, not a *lacemaking course*. But, two of the braids are of my own invention, and one is so "varied" it was simpler to draw a diagram, than try to describe it. Hence the 3 diagrams (4, if you count the mirrored image as a separate entity)... Some sewings are "side", some "top"... All are done one way or the other *on purpose*; the *how* is to be found in the books, but I need to "flag" them with every braid, because the photos aren't likely to show it... etc, etc. And that's just for a 2-colour (white and gold) "confection"; if I had to document the "technicolour" version I'm now working on, I'd have to produce something along the lines of Sandi Woods' "Special Effects in ML" (and go ga-ga in the process <g>)...
Lorelei wrote:
I don't think it is reasonable for a beginner to expect to learn basic bobbin lace techniques from a pattern published in the bulletin.
Until fairly recently (the past 2-3 years), the (admittedly, *unconfirmed*) "scuttlebutt" among those who contributed with some regularity was that all BL patterns aimed for publication in IOLI were to be simple -- Torchon and basic tape (cloth and half stitch) for preference, with *geometric* Bucks for "desert". And as much in the way of instructions as you could cram, to broaden the appeal and "cover" the semi-beginners as well as the intermediates (presumably, there were no "advanced's" to be had). Which is why, for several years, I'd been sending the more complex patterns (which assume more knowledge of the basics) to Lace, rather than IOLI.
Things have changed; whether it's because I'd been mis-informed in the first place, or the general level of lacemaking standard in the US has risen, or because the editors were so "starved" for patterns they'd accept anything, I do not know. But, between the more ready acceptance of "not for beginners" and the colour, I'll be more likely to send *both* types of patterns to IOLI now that I had been 3 yrs ago
It seems to me that these contests serve to inspire lacemakers to add to the wealth of designs that all lacemakers can draw from.
We all have different points of view (thank goodness <g>)... Since I'm a "rude mechanical" rather than an "artist", my first priority is to design patterns that other people might be tempted to reproduce and use, and to make it *possible* for them to do so. The patterns which "add to the wealth" but without the means to repeat/re-interpret are, for me, so much "eye candy".
Beginners should be working through a book aimed at beginners,
Or, with a teacher, yes. *To an extent*. I totally agree with Jane (Partridge) that, at least *some* of the patterns published in magazines should be an extension of the *beginner's* horizon, a "bait" *almost* within one's reach, rather than a beaten path of the "same old, same old, step by small step". And, if they want to stretch their wings a bit beyond what's provided by any particular book/teacher (same thing, in the long run), they should be helped, not hampered...
IMO (also not at all humble <g>), a magazine/newsletter/bulletin (a rose by any other name) which provides patterns of only one level of standard -- be it advanced or beginner -- is likely to be read by a very small group of people... Since "it" (mag, etc) is likely to be one's most important connection to a lace group/guild, and since it's likely to be the biggest (if not *only*, depending on the size of the country) "magnet" for joining, I think it should cater to *all*.
Of course, "elitism" was a dirty word in (communist) Poland of my childhood, so I have a skewed view of things... :)
Back to Janice:
I would also like some feedback after the competition on why a particular piece did not win.
I'd like to have feedback even if the piece *did* win :) Got it, in '91, but that was the only time (have entered twice since; this year's is the 3rd)
----- Tamara P Duvall mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Lexington, Virginia, USA Formerly of Warsaw, Poland - To unsubscribe send email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] containing the line: unsubscribe lace [EMAIL PROTECTED]
