On 21 Feb 2011, at 03:32, Paul Sheer wrote:

>> 
>> [...] But so what?  It'll report 00:00:03 Monday when it's "really"
>> 23:59:57 Sunday --- why is this small number of seconds any more
>> important than any other small number of seconds error?  [...]
>> 
> 
> 
> A miss is as good as a mile when a timestamp is an index into a hash
> table.

So let's try to understand your use-case.  Machine A, which is isolated from 
the outside world and unable to perform leap-second adjustment but maintains a 
stable clock with a CsRb , is generating hashes, alongside Machine B, which is 
performing leap-second adjustment via (for the sake of argument) NTP or GPS., 
and those hashes are being used as indexes into a hash table that both A and B 
read and write?   Yes, I can see leap-second would cause a problem there, 
except (a) the engineering design is insane and (b) even if it isn't, TAI is 
ready and waiting to solve their needs.  Has anyone, anywhere, written a system 
so stupid and not been locked up?

> 
> These systems don't care whether the event really did happen at
> 12:34:56pm nor whether the clock was a few minutes slow that day.
> 
> But they DO care that they are talking about the SAME event!!!
> 

So how is a leap second (or, more to the point, 120 leap seconds) any different 
to "a few minutes slow"?   Two systems are communicating.  One applies a leap 
second the other doesn't know about via nasty slewing over the course of an 
hour.  Two other systems are communicating.  One loses a second relative to the 
other through thermal effects.  Describe how an outside observer might 
distinguish those scenarios given a sequence of timestamps from the systems.  


> 
> Imagine a complex business environment represented by a large block
> diagram. Data, including fields that contain timestamps, propagate
> around this block diagram -

A complex business environment which nonetheless cannot perform one bit of I/O 
per eighteen months.  A complex business system which nonetheless cannot 
interact with NTP, MSF/DCF77/WWV or GPS?  I think you're making something up to 
bolster a point, not referring to any real business environment.

ian
_______________________________________________
LEAPSECS mailing list
[email protected]
http://six.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/leapsecs

Reply via email to