Hehe, seems I was quite fast :) I've reported the bug to bugzilla, thanks for taking care of it John :)
//Paggas Den tisdag 1 mars 2016 kl. 23:04:02 UTC skrev Yuval Hager: > > On 03/01/2016 01:21 PM, Paggas wrote: > > Hello ledger mailing list! > > > > I've just noticed a possible bug in ledger. The idea is that, when > there > > is a null-amount posting which balances multiple commodities in the > > transaction, any automatic transactions that get activated on that > posting > > will only run for one of the commodities. > > Perfect timing! I just ran into the same issue last night, and prepared an > example file, but you beat me to sending it :) > > Here's the file I prepared. I am circumventing it by splitting each > transaction > with multiple commodities to multiple transactions with a single commodity > in each. > > > ---- automated.dat ------ > ; > ; I have two commodities defined, each priced at 8.56 kr ($1): > ; > P 2016-01-01 00:00:00 ABC 8.56 kr ($1) > P 2016-01-01 00:00:00 DEF 8.56 kr ($1) > > ; And I defined an automated transaction to add a tax amount to the > ; bill, while increasing my tax liability, every time I use the tax > ; tag: > ; > = %/tax/ > $account 0.05 > liabilities:tax -0.05 > > ; > ; These two transactions from February do exactly what I want. 42.81 kr > ($5) is > ; added to X, and the liabilities:tax gets additional negative 42.81 kr > ($5) with > ; each transaction > ; > 2016-02-01 foo > X ; :tax: > Y -100 ABC > > 2016-02-01 foo > X ; :tax: > Z -100 DEF > > ; > ; with the following transaction, X is increased by 1,712.33 kr ($200,), > so I expect > ; my tax liability to grow by 85.62 kr ($10,), but in fact, it only > grows by > ; 42.81 kr ($5.). As if only one of the commodities is "seen" by the > automated > ; transaction, and the other is ignored. > ; > 2016-03-01 bar > X ; :tax: > Y -100 ABC > Z -100 DEF > > > ; > ; Here are the generated transactions: > ; > comment > > $ ledger -f automated.dat print --generated > 2016/02/01 foo > X 100 ABC ; :mytag: > Y -100 ABC > X 5 ABC > liabilities:tax -5 ABC > > 2016/02/01 foo > X 100 DEF ; :mytag: > Z -100 DEF > X 5 DEF > liabilities:tax -5 DEF > > 2016/03/01 bar > X 100 ABC ; :mytag: > Y -100 ABC > Z -100 DEF > X 100 DEF > X 5 ABC > liabilities:tax -5 ABC > > ; > ; and the balance report shows tax liability of -128.42 kr ($15,), > instead of the > ; expected $-20: > ; > > $ ledger -f automated.dat bal -H > 3,553.08 kr ($415) X > $-200 Y > $-200 Z > $-15 liabilities:tax > -------------------- > 0 > > end comment > > -- --- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "Ledger" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to [email protected]. For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.
