for the off side goal, the linesman did flag but very late - I think he
waited until howson actually touched the ball rather than anyone else.
It wasn't offside though!
----- Original Message -----
From: "Richard Walker" <richleed...@yahoo.co.uk>
To: "Ian Murray" <ianjamesmur...@hotmail.com>; <leedslist@gn.apc.org>
Sent: Saturday, December 04, 2010 8:02 PM
Subject: [LU] Palace
What a great afternoon – didn’t even seem cold. We deserved the win, no
doubt
about that but Palace came to win also and troubled us throughout the 90
mins –
more than they should have.
So when I saw the line up I went ballastic, 4-5-1 with Becchio as the lone
striker. Good God Simon get a grip, we shouldn’t be playing like this
against a
bottom of the league team at home. Also, with Bradley Johnson holding the
fort
in central midfield nothings going to happen. This system relies heavily
on
runners from midfield breaking though because Becchio’s movement his
limited so
he really doesn’t have much of a role in this system. For 50 minutes we
huffed
and puffed, played some nice football, created some good chances and made
lots
of mistakes, missed some real sitters, had a great goal chalked off by the
ref
(not the linesman) and made some really basic errors which helped Palace
go in
1-0. It could have easily have been 2 if it hadn’t been for a great
Schmeichel
save on 45 minutes.
First that ‘off-side’ goal. Great movement and great running from Howson
saw him
played through. He took the goal brilliantly, took a look at the linesman
who
had his flag down then slid on his knees and saluted the south stand. The
ref
then unbelievable cut short the celebrations and pulled back play – we
were
still dancing in the stands. I always take a glance at the linesman before
I go
mental and although it did look close the linesman was in the best
position to
judge whether Howson was off-side and he decided not. Really bad
officiating.
We continued to create chances and then make mistakes. The best chances
fell to
Becchio, who lets be honest, should have had 6 today. The worse miss was a
ball
in to him, He was stood 2 yards from goal but failed to convert – he was
hesitant which is strange because he’s usually full on when he’s in the 6
yard
box. Becchio was then presented with a free 6 yard box header but he
tamely
headed on to the bar. Howson and Gradel also missed good chances. Towards
the
end of the half though we lost our way. Johnson started to detioriate and
passes
started going astray. Gradel changed wings to try and be more effective ,
but it
just wasn’t working. I watched attack after attack where we neatly played
ourselves up to the edge of the box but nobody was making the runs behind
their
defence. Becchio in particularly is clueless when it comes to making runs
like
this and plays most of the game with his back to the goal. He really
shouldn’t
be the striker if we want to play 4-5-1 at home.
Then there was their goal. Johnson got caught out on the left, he didn’t
have
the pace to recover leaving their man in. He crossed and converted 1-0.
They
didn’t deserve it but we really hadn’t played well enough. The system wasn’t
working and Grayson has to change it at the break.
Amazingly he didn’t ! Shocking really. So for another 10 minutes we
laboured,
same formation same problems. It was beginning to turn into a nightmare
then
Simon jumped into life. He dragged Johnson and Gradel off and out on
McCormack
and Sam. Now I’m no fan of Bradley Johnson and as far as I’m concerned he
can go
now because he’s not good enough for this league never mind the
premiership
(what a dreamer his agent must be) but he was badly booed when he left the
field
which I thought was out of order. I’d ask those fans to boo the manager
for
picking him not Johnson who to his credit is trying his best – it’s just
that
this is not good enough, never has been.
The subs changed the formation and changed the match. Suddenly we were
4-4-2
which Kilkenny and Howson central (strange that isn’t it !!???) and a
winger in
Sam who actually was lively and caused a threat. McCormack was brilliant.
He was
lively, he made runs, he controlled the ball well, he had a goal
disallowed and
according to Grayson he got the equaliser (need to see it again). The goal
was
coming though. Kilkenny had nearly equalised when he brilliantly brought
the
ball down with his right foot, flicked it on to his left and volleyed from
25
yards. It was straight at the keeper which was good for him because he
knew nowt
about it. Then Becchio had another free 6 yard header which was easier to
score
instead he too put it straight at the keeper. He shook his head, he knew
he
should have scored.
The equaliser to be honest is a bit of a blur but it looked like a few
people
tried things and it just seemed to come out to Becchio. He had his back to
goal
but managed to turn and hit it. Maybe it McCormack on the way on, who
knows, it
was Becchio’s goal.
Palace to their credit came at us again and again and we wobbled a bit but
when
Paynter came on for Hughes we looked like we’d score with every attack. We
tore
them apart. The winner when it came was another strange goal. The lively
McCormack was fouled as he pushed forward, I think everyone stopped for a
while
but the ball came nicely to Becchio who his a side footer – it looked like
it
should have been saved but it ended up in the back of the net. We went
mad, me
and a mate ended up 2 rows down. It was a good atmosphere today in the
last 20
mins.
We didn’t give up there either and we could have had more. I think the
Sam,
Paynter and McCormack combination has real potential. This was a great
win.
Scores:
Schmeicel – 7. A couple of good saves but his kicking was dodgy today and
he
does risk it a bit which nearly cost us a goal in the 2nd half as he was
charged
down.
Hughes – 4. Maybe the defensive wobbles were because Connelly wasn’t
playing. I
think Hughes unbalanced the back 4. He isn’t a right back, he’s not good
enough
despite tremendous effort.
McCartney – 6. Slightly worried about his defensive abilities at times, he
gets
turned very easily.
OBrien – 7. Steady and calming influence.
Bruce – 7. Many good tackles and last ditch defending. I think these two
have
real potential.
Johnson – 4. Thought he started positively enough but he doesn’t have
enough
about him and definitely not enough ability.
Gradel – 5. Not his day today. Lively at first but the Palace defenders
actually
had a bit of pace and didn’t give him an inch. Was subbed and it was the
right
decision.
Howson – 7. Very lively throughout. Not everything came off, but he is our
main
player.
Kilkenny – 7. Our best midfielder. Not everything came off, there were a
few bad
challenges and at times you just wish he had an extra yard of pace.
However, he
controls the game, he gets hold of the ball and he makes things happen. He
also
talks a lot and he tells players where they should be and what they should
be
doing. I don’t see captain Howson doing this. Our best footballer.
Snodgrass – 7. I thought he played well today, they couldn’t handle him at
times. Sometimes though he just looks a little bit slugglish.
Becchio – 6 (3 for each goal). Ok, here we go. I’ve lost the bet before
Christmas which I really didn’t expect so I’ve had a think about why I
lost so
spectacularly ? Was I wrong about Becchio ? Is he a better player than I
give
him credit for ? Does he have more pace than I think ? Is he winning more
balls
in the air than I can see ? Well, my summary is this. I think he’s
improved a
lot since last season and I believe he is a player at the top of his game.
I
also think that the area I have completely underestimated him on is his
Chapman
factor. The ability to be in the right place at the right time. Today he
should
have had a double hat-trick and that’s because he got himself into the
right
places. His goals today weren’t what you can call quality goals but he was
there, ready to finish off even if he wasn’t pretty. I think there’s a lot
of
value in someone like that and if he’s putting a few away then all the
better.
So for that reason I will admit that I have underestimated him a bit as a
striker. There are plenty of strikers out there with much more ability
than
Becchio that never get in to decent positions to apply their talent.
Having said that, I still believe:
1) Becchio is not the best option in a 4-5-1 at home when we’re looking to
break down and outfox defences.
2) His aerial ability is poor.
3) His general ability is at best average.
4) He has no pace
A million pounds !!! F*ck me, snap their hands off.
Ian, where do you want the cheque sending. Send me a mail off list.
Subs:
McCormack – 8. Lively, aware and made things happen.
Sam – 8. Ditto
Paynter – 7. Looked lively, maybe should have scored.
Grayson – two ways of looking at this.
1) He’s a genius because he realises he needs to change things and when he
does it works
2) He’s a numpty because he keeps putting out a 4-5-1 , it doesn’t work so
we have to change and go chasing the game. It’s like entering a race with
a leg
iron on and then taking it off after 50 metres and then destroying the
competition. Why not start the race without the leg iron and obliterate
them ?
Crowd – bit of a Christmassy feel today, had a really good day. Looking
forward
to 18th when I’m on an all dayer.
Going up ? Only 5 points behind Bardiff now.
_______________________________________________
Leedslist mailing list
Info and options:
http://mailman-new.greennet.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/leedslist
To unsubscribe, email leedslist-unsubscr...@gn.apc.org
MARCHING ON TOGETHER
_______________________________________________
Leedslist mailing list
Info and options: http://mailman-new.greennet.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/leedslist
To unsubscribe, email leedslist-unsubscr...@gn.apc.org
MARCHING ON TOGETHER
