US firm sues Rio Tinto
http://finance.news.com.au/0,3546,1176349%255E462,00.html
By John Phaceas
08sep00

RIO Tinto has slammed an Ok Tedi-style class action over alleged human 
rights abuses and environmental damage at its now closed Panguna copper 
mine on Bougainville Island as "without foundation".

Under an obscure US law, Seattle-based lawyer Steven Berman yesterday filed 
a class action in the US District Court of San Francisco on behalf of 
villagers adversely affected by the mine and the 10-year civil war which 
followed its closure in 1989.

The action alleges mining and processing operations destroyed the 
environment of the island, and subsequently the traditional livelihoods of 
local people. The suit also alleges Rio "stepped in and assisted" PNG 
troops fighting the rebels, including the provision of helicopters, turning 
the PNG army "into their private police force".

But Rio dismissed all allegations outright.

"We categorically reject all allegations of human

rights abuses and environmental damage on Bougainville," a Rio spokesman 
said yesterday.

"And our view is that this issue should be resolved in PNG, not in a 
foreign court by foreign lawyers running the case on a contingency

basis."

Asked whether Rio had ever assisted PNG troops in

any way, the spokesman said "absolutely not � and Bougainville Copper never 
even had any helicopters".

Rio subsidiary Bougainville Copper operated the Panguna mine from 1972 
until 1989, when attacks from Bougainvillean rebels seeking independence 
from PNG forced it to evacuate and abandon what was then the world's 
biggest open-pit mine.

Until a UN-backed ceasefire was implemented last year, the PNG Government 
continued to actively engage the secessionist Bougainville Revolutionary 
Army. The suit claims the war resulted in the deaths of at least 25,000 
Bougainvillean civilians.

Mr Berman filed the action under the US Alien Tort Claims Act, which allows 
foreign nationals to sue US companies alleged to have violated 
international law. Though Rio is headquartered in London, the Borax 
subsidiary is registered in California.

Mr Berman claimed a fair trial in PNG would be impossible, while courts in 
Australia and the UK do not recognise such cases. Mr Berman will be 
assisted by Melbourne-based Slater & Gordon, now suing BHP for the second 
time over damage caused by its Ok Tedi copper mine in PNG.

Rio is expected to argue US courts have no jurisdiction in the matter.

--

           Leftlink - Australia's Broad Left Mailing List
                            mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
        Archived at http://www.cat.org.au/lists/leftlink/

Sponsored by Melbourne's New International Bookshop
Subscribe: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]?Body=subscribe%20leftlink
Unsubscribe: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]?Body=unsubscribe%20leftlink


Reply via email to