I've just completed xorg on a new blfs-9.0 SysV build. Here are some observations.

I used Pierre's build order that he posted some time ago. I've listed that below with some modifications. The asterisks indicate that the package was installed, the dash indicates it was skipped. The indented entries show packages I installed that were not in the jhalfs list.

Overall I liked the generated list as it made the order much easier to follow.

I ran into a bit of a problem when starting Xorg. It came up but I had no mouse or keyboard input. There was also a problem finding Xorg.0.log to see what was happening. It is in ~/.local/share/xorg/Xorg.0.log. That is documented in the Testing and Configuration section for systemd. I will change it so it is reflected in both books now that we are using elogind.

I had not started dbus or elogind. After starting those, the xorg input still did not work. I then rebooted and the mouse and keyboard worked fine. I think a logout and login may have been sufficient, but I'm not sure. I'm not sure how to address this. It would only be a one-time issue. Should we recommend a reboot before starting xorg for the first time? logout/in?

We probably need to adjust some dependencies. shadow really should have cracklib. pam should probably have a shadow as a recommended runtime dependency.

The xcb-util-* files are only needed for qt, but it's easy to do them in the book order.

libva has a circular dependency with mesa.

make-ca probably should have wget as a recommended runtime dependency.

I do not know of a way to get jhalfs to add in drivers. Perhaps an output line to tell the user to install the appropriate drivers for the system HW would be sufficient.

I'd like to get some additional opinions about these issues.

I will start tagging the packages below in a few minutes.

  -- Bruce

================
Here is the generated order, when ticking:
X + Window and Display Managers
     ->X Window System Environment
           ->xinit 1.4.1
-------------------->8---------
* python2
* libuv
* curl
* libarchive
* cmake
* zip
* llvm
* icu
* libxml2
* sgml-common
* unzip
* DocBook xml-4.5
* docbook-xsl 1.79.2
* libxslt
* pcre-8.43
* glib2
* graphite2-pass1
* libpng
* which
* freetype2-pass1
* MarkupSafe
* Mako
* gobject-introspection
* harfbuzz
* freetype2
* fontconfig
* xorg-env
* util-macros
* xorgproto
* libXau
* xcb-proto
* libXdmcp
* libxcb
* dbus-pass1
   * cracklib
* linux-pam
   * shadow
* elogind
* Xorg libraries
* dbus
   * xcb-util
   * xcb-util-image
   * xcb-util-keysyms
   * xcb-util-renderutil
   * xcb-util-wm
   * xcb-util-cursor
- xinit
* pixman
* libdrm
* wayland
* libva
* libvdpau
* wayland-protocols
* mesa
  * libva-pass2
* xbitmaps
- xcb-util
* Xorg Applications
* xcursor-themes
* Xorg fonts
* autoconf213
* nspr
* js60
* polkit
* libepoxy
* xorg-server
* xkeyboard-config
* Xorg Legacy
   * libevdev-1.7.0
   * mtdev-1.1.5
   * xf86-input-evdev-2.10.6
   * libinput-1.14.0
   * xf86-input-libinput-0.29.0
   * xf86-video-fbdev-0.5.0
   * xf86-video-nouveau-1.0.16
* twm
* xclock
* xterm2
  * xinit
* libtasn1
* p11-kit
* make-ca
  * wget

--
http://lists.linuxfromscratch.org/listinfo/blfs-dev
FAQ: http://www.linuxfromscratch.org/blfs/faq.html
Unsubscribe: See the above information page

Reply via email to