On Saturday 29 December 2012 15:40:42 Luca Barbato wrote:
> The problem might be in actually sorting out the specific DVD file
> system. Or so does look to me (more below)
>
> > Apparently this is not the case and you do not seem to consider it a bug
> > in libav or whatever else is involved.
>
> Looks like that the problem lies in deciphering the dvd, I asked you to
> use vlc since it shouldn't use libav for muxing back the streams so I
> can figure out if the problem is in libav (muxing many stream in mpeg
> ps) or in actually getting the streams out of the dvd.
Hi Lu.
Ok, let's try this the other way round: consider me a noob in the sense of
DVDs like DVD structures, encoding, cypher, muxing, anything related. I got
these DVDs I want to back up. Most can be read fine by the tools as they are,
others act up in the way described. Since I'm the one who has the DVD and I'm
the one who wants to back them up, I'm probably the one who should consider
fixing/updating the tools to handle them?
Now assume that I know my way around code. Where should I start looking? How
can I reduce the problem to a minimal piece of software and library
dependencies that still work and show the problem in a reasonable amount of
time? Are there any bare test tools that I can use as a starting point?
I realise that this is possibly outside the realm of libav, but, for example,
digging myself through not less than 130 libraries to extract the bits and
pieces needed from mplayer is not my cup of tea right now ...
$ ldd `which mplayer` | wc -l
130
Thanks
Daniel
_______________________________________________
libav-tools mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.libav.org/mailman/listinfo/libav-tools
