Good morning again, Tim!

Tim Bedding wrote to Frank Reichert...

I previously wrote:
> > Again, I consider
> > it a far stretch to assume that individuals who strongly oppose a
> > winning Candidate, have some tacit obligation to accept such an
> > individual as their Representative.

To which, you replied:
> Taking your argument to its logical conclusion, you would
> say also that George Bush is not the President since you
> did not vote for him.

Again, as Bill as done, you confuse and mingle two entities
together as if they are one, e.g.: the individual, and the State.

I never wrote that a Representative that I did not vote for, or
even strongly opposed, was not a Representative.  He or she is a
Representative of the State of Idaho in the case of our national
State delegation.  In your above example, The Shrub<tm>
unfortunately IS the President of the United States, sadly, even
though his actions and performance in that office doesn't
Represent me.

In fact, as polarized as the U.S. body politic is today, I doubt
that the Shrub Regime<tm> is the represenative of a significant
majority of the population, as many are not only strongly
opposed, but visibly demonstrate in the streets their opposigion
to many of the policies of this regime.

The issue at hand therefore, and one in which Bill Anderson and I
have been discussing, centres around who is the Represents a
particular individual, not who Represents a particular State, or
country. Every individual makes either a tacit or voluntary
choice whether or not a political office holder represents them
or not.  Bill strongly suggests that I am somehow bound to
acknowledge that even a Representative, or in your case, this
President that I strongly oppose, is my Representative.

If you believe that Bill's argument here is the correct one, then
this certainly implies that individuals are the victims of
coersion and force, a have no right to choose for themselves who
represents them, their issues, convictions and position on
various matters.

Kindest regards,
Frank

_______________________________________________
Libnw mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
List info and subscriber options: http://immosys.com/mailman/listinfo/libnw
Archives: http://immosys.com/mailman//pipermail/libnw

Reply via email to