https://bugs.freedesktop.org/show_bug.cgi?id=53570
--- Comment #16 from Harald Koester <[email protected]> --- Created attachment 79725 --> https://bugs.freedesktop.org/attachment.cgi?id=79725&action=edit Example file I think I observed the same bug with a little png file where I changed the file extension from "png" to "xxx" and tried to open it. I will provide this file as attachment. I made some more tests with this file. The result depends on from where you open this file: (1) From the Start Center: File is opened with Draw. OK! (2) From Writer: A text document is opened. Not OK !! Expected: Either opening with Draw (best case) or a message according to comment 14 or provide an organized list where the user can select an appropriate file format according the proposal of bug 41000. (3) From Calc: Dialog "Text Import" is displayed. I assume that this dialog is meant with "CSV import dialog" of the initial description. To my opinion not OK, hence LibroOffice assumes that the file is a text file which should be imported to a spreadsheet. But this is not the case !! Expected: Either opening with Draw (best case) or a message according to comment 14 or provide an organized list where the user can select an appropriate file format according to the proposal of bug 41000. (4) From Impress, Draw, Math: File is opened with Draw. OK! I did the same tests with a LO installation where I deselected the installation component "Graphic Filters". In this case the result is different: (1) From the Start Center with "Open...", Calc, Impress, Draw and Math: Dialog "Text Import" is displayed. To my opinion not OK, hence LibroOffice assumes that the file is a text file which should be imported to a spreadsheet. And this is not the case !! Expected: Either a message according to comment 14 or provide an organized list where the user can select an appropriate file format according to the proposal of bug 41000. (2) From Writer: A text document is opened. Not OK !! Expected: Either a message according to comment 14 is displayed or provide an organized list where the user can select an appropriate file format according the proposal of bug 41000. In order to reproduce the bug, download the attached document and try to open it under the mentioned conditions. Just an idea: What about a message something like: "Unable to detect a format of <filename.ext>" [Open as text] [Open as spreadsheet] [Open other format] [Cancel] And then if the user clicks "Open other format" s/he gets the full list of possible formats. OS: Win 7, LO version: 4.0.3 -- You are receiving this mail because: You are the assignee for the bug.
_______________________________________________ Libreoffice-bugs mailing list [email protected] http://lists.freedesktop.org/mailman/listinfo/libreoffice-bugs
