https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=143340
--- Comment #33 from [email protected] <[email protected]> --- (In reply to Telesto from comment #31) > (In reply to [email protected] from comment #29) > > I see the "Keep Ratio" setting no longer as a property that needs to be > > saved in the document [see also my comment #26]. Because the UI of Image > > properties dialog is changed in 24.8 (checkbox "Keep ratio" replaced by a > > lock icon) I propose to put no effort into solving this bug but to close it. > > Are you sure: > > 1. open attached document "Test_Bildgröße_V2_keep_ratio_off.odt" > 2. select the image and open the properties dialog -> KeepRatio is unchecked > 3. check KeepRatio + exit by OK > 4. Result: the Undo arrow (gray; disabled)/ Redo arrow (gray: disabled) No > red point is added to the Save icon > 5. Save > 6. select the image and open the properties dialog again-> KeepRatio is > still checked -> So apparently saved (as far I can tell) It is true: This behavior can be reproduced with LO 24.2 and also with LO 24.8 (changed UI: Lock symbol instead a checkbox)), means the original problem was not solved. But as I have written in Comment 29 I see "Keep Ratio" no longer as a document property necessary to be saved in the document because it doesn't influence the appearance of the document. I see it as a setting that makes easier to change image properties Width and Height in the Image properties dialog. This is like e.g. the autocorrection options (Ignore dubble spaces etc.), also not saved within the document (AFAIK). Therefore I have proposed to close the bug. On the other hand remains the question how this setting should be set initially or as default when the Image properties dialog is called. One way could be to use always a default value - for images e.g. "Height Widht ratio is locked" ("Keep ratio" checked) - means the choosen setting is used only once . An other way could be to keep this setting for further calls and possibly to save it anywhere, e.g. in "Settings.xml" how is realized currently (then valid only for this document) or within the LO options. Nevertheless I see no need to mark the document as changed and to activate "Undo" when the setting is changed. See also my Comment 26! I think this cannot be object of a bug report but e.g a proposal for enhancement. -- You are receiving this mail because: You are the assignee for the bug.
