https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=132780

--- Comment #40 from Baelor <[email protected]> ---
I just tried this using your explanation. Yes, it works sort of, but it lacks
so much functionality and simplicity for the user compared to Excel, this
really merits a feature request.
0) Feature is hidden away in tab "Data".
1) No visual indication, that a range is even existing and how big it is.
2) New rows or columns are not added automatically.
3) No auto-replace of absolute cell adresses with cell range names within
formulas.
4) No formatting options.

PS: There are also data ranges in Excel and they behave similar to these in
Calc. But "format as a table" adresses a different need and is not treated the
same way.

**********
As a long-time Excel user I made multiple attempts to switch to OOCalc and
later LibreOffice Calc but it was (and is!) this missing feature "Format as
table" that got me. This is **THE** feature of Excel that permits:
- very fast and easy and clear structuring of data, 
- low risk of formula errors as well as 
- easy maintainability. 
Lots of the classic errors of tabular calculations can be avoided with this (on
the surface) simple feature and therefore I use it wherever possible.
**********

I really would like to see this implemented in an open-source solution because
I want to finally ditch Excel and Microsoft. I would sponsor this feature with
money, if this is possible. I have the yearly billing for Office 365 that I can
allocate to this feature for LibreOffice, if someone takes up the ball.

(In reply to Regina Henschel from comment #37)
> (In reply to John Mills from comment #36)
> > (In reply to Pedro from comment #35)
> > > There's so many differences than it's not even funny.
> 
> > > We can start with name: Database range is meaningless to the common user.
> > > One can't even fathom it is supposed to be a similar functionality (hence
> > > why it was placed in Data tab in Tabbed UI instead of Insert tab. In 
> > > Excel,
> > > Table is in Insert tab).
> > > Scope there: 
> > > 1 - Change name of "Define Range" uno command to Table.
> > > 2 - Move command from Data Tab to Insert tab in Tabbed UI.
> 
> There is no "Table" inserted. Compare with what happens, when you use
> "Insert Table" in Writer or Impress. The term "Database Range" describes the
> purpose and the features better than the term "Table". The term "Table"
> means all of the cells.
> That name "Database Range" exists for more than 25 years. OpenOffice and
> LibreOffice users know it. Coming from Excel you simple need to learn, that
> it is "Database Range" in LibreOffice.

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are the assignee for the bug.

Reply via email to