https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=167250
--- Comment #20 from Sahil Gautam <[email protected]> --- (In reply to Eyal Rozenberg from comment #18) > Screenshots: > > Sahil you've added some screenshots, but their names don't clarify how they > relate to the bug. these screenshots show various user interfaces with fluent design icons (i replaced some of the colibre icons with some fluent design icons). you can find the fluent ones on the left side. > Anyway, I would like to ask that you post some screenshots which illustrate > some/most/all problems on your list, hopefully in comparison to other > Windows GUI apps (not necessarily MSO). will do soon. > > > 1. no proper toolbar background color, or separators for distinction > > between the toolbar region and the document region. > > I see a different BG color and a separator line, of sorts, both for standard > and tabbed UI on Win11 with a recent LO 26.2 nightly (and Light theme). Are > we talking about feedback for earlier versions of LO? Or is there something > I'm missing? let me check that once again, i checked it in dark mode, maybe on 25.2.. > > 2. crowdedness in the tabbed ui > > Please explain. Too many buttons? Not enough large buttons? Not enough > buttons with label? Not enough space between buttons? Something else? no, it's mostly about lack of layout planning. the ribbon follows a proper scheme throughout, large buttons with label at the bottom and taking, or columns of small buttons, or columns of checkboxes. > > 3. boxy old school tabs > > Is this different from the "sharp corners" point? yes, it's a separate action item as tabs are drawn differently than buttons, buttons are just rectangles. > > 4. calc fitting way more cells at 100% compared to excel. comparison with > > excel is even more important here as that's what the users use as the > > baseline while comparing. > > Do you mean the default zoom setting, or defaults for column widths? Row > heights? yes at 100% zoom and same window size we fit 28 rows whereas excel fits 21 rows, and the cell width in excel is also less than ours. > > 5. sharp corners in buttons, menus, menu highlights and various widgets like > > dropdowns.. > > 6. flat, sharp cornered icons. > > You mean the icons, not the buttons with icons on them, right? Ok, so can > you give an example of the "flatness" of an icon, and of icons with "sharp > corners"? all the screenshots shared till this comment demonstrate just that, there's a wifi icon example. windows 11's icons are way different from windows 10's, they have a "3D-ish" look. > > 9. lack of smooth cell focus rectangle animations in calc > > You mean, an animation of moving the focus from one cell to another? yes > > 12. sharp corners on treeview boxes, searchboxes and edit boxes > > 13. missing preview expander widget for the tabbed ui. > > What is a "preview expander widget"? And where exactly in the tabbed UI is > it missing? if you open writer with tabbed ui, you would see the styles preview on the home tab. note that mso also has similar widgets all over and they have a dropdown button to the right of this preview which on click creates a dropdown with a lot more options. > > 14. missing animation controls/previews from the toolbar, they are on the > > sidebar but most of the users migrating from mso are not familiar with it, > > we need those on the notebookbar as well. > > Do you believe a more prominent position (and size) of the tabbed bar button > which expands the animation sidebar, would help, if only as a stop-gap > measure? expands the animation sidebar? i am talking about a new tab called "Slide Show" or "Animations", which provides buttons and controls and dropdowns with icons (which the sidebar currently has) like the "Animations" tab in Power Point https://support.microsoft.com/images/en-us/b92cdac9-05aa-424a-a448-b0e41f4f9479. -- You are receiving this mail because: You are the assignee for the bug.
