https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=170416

--- Comment #1 from ady <[email protected]> ---
I am not convinced that dealing with #FMT should be the same as with ###.

Example:

1. On a new spreadsheet, narrow down the width of column A so only 4 characters
could be seen (e.g. cell A1: 1234 and then narrow down the width of the
column).
2. Cell A2: 12345 [enter]; the ### "error" is displayed on cell A2, while the
numeric value is still usable.
3. Cell A3: 123456789 [enter]; the ### "error" is displayed on cell A3, while
the numeric value is still usable.
4. Click once on the column A header, so all the cells in it are now selected.
5. Change the cell format to Date.
5.1. Cells A1 and A2 still show the same "###", whereas cell A3 shows "#FMT".

While, in theory, all those numeric values are still "usable", the value in A3
(123456789) has no valid meaning as a Date (the internal serial number would be
out of the valid range for a date).

So, in theory, you could still use the value in cell A3, but the #FMT error is
telling you that something else is probably "not quite correct". Showing the
numeric value in the status bar instead of showing #FMT would "provide a
misleading hint", instead of actually providing a real hint (as currently
intended).

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are the assignee for the bug.

Reply via email to