https://bugs.freedesktop.org/show_bug.cgi?id=66985

--- Comment #10 from Parameshwara Bhat <[email protected]> ---
(In reply to comment #9)
> After all I think that everything works as expected. The sheet looks the
> same in MS Office and LO. 

you are missing the important point. You may check it when you have opened the
file in MSO. It lets you work with numbers as numbers and dates as dates.It
senses the true nature of data. It will keep them left aligned, but will not
come in the way of doing any mathematical operation on them.

In LO, you cannot do any mathematical operation on them. If you highlight
multiple cells, sum of the cells is zero.The numbers with apostrophe behind are
shown as numbers in cell format dialog. You change them to specific number
format, no error is generated.But there is no change in the status either. You
will not be able to convert them.

so, to deal with them you either have to manually and tediously remove
apostrophes, or resort to ugly hacks like " find '^.' and replace with '&' ".
Finding ' and replacing with nothing did not work for me, though some people
have reported it to work. LO fails to find apostrophe. Anyway,they are not for
common users. As far as common users are concerned, the file from the Bank is
not workable. Removing apostrophes manually is way too tedious for large
data.Changing the format will not work. 

Interestingly, calligra sheets  will open the file perfectly and let you work
with numbers as numbers and date as dates though they are left aligned as they
are formatted as text. additionally, when I see the cell format property, it
will correctly show the format as text, not as general number.Even then,without
changing the format, it will let you work with numbers as numbers and date as
dates. If you change the format to number, it will save the cell as number when
saved even in OD format and remember it as number when opened again. But this
ods file if opened in LO will still be showing the numbers as text and not deal
with them as numbers. You open the same ods file again in calligra sheet, the
reformatted cells would remain re-formatted.


It is not a question of formatting. It is a question of dealing with data.
Formatting a numerical data as text with apostrophe is end of story in LO for
that number. You cannot have it as number again through any means other than
physically removing apostrophe or hacking at it.

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are the assignee for the bug.
_______________________________________________
Libreoffice-bugs mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.freedesktop.org/mailman/listinfo/libreoffice-bugs

Reply via email to