https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=172899

--- Comment #9 from MartinPC <[email protected]> ---
(In reply to Heiko Tietze from comment #8)
> The topic was on the agenda of the design meeting but did not receive
> further comments.
> 
> Besides the aesthetics all use cases are covered, maybe not to everyone's
> full convenience but in general working well. Resolving as WONTFIX
> therefore, feel free to reopen.

I know this is an inconsequential issue to folks who don't make heavy use of
conditional hyphens, but it can be quite an annoyance to those of us who DO
(especially if we have marginal eyesight, as it makes text more tiring to
proofread).

I'm a non-coder, but it seems to me that this problem is likely a whole lot
easier to fix than, for example, the atrocious character spacing that can
result from the interaction of obsolete LibreOffice code and the HarfBuzz
text-shaping engine. Both problems make for a poorly finished, non-professional
look and feel. In that connection, a lot of European governments/​agencies are
apparently poised (once again!) to switch away from proprietary, foreign-owned
OSes and apps for reasons of national security and digital sovereignty. If *I*
were positioning LibreOffice to compete against the likes of Collabora,
OpenOffice, and Euro-Office — and maybe for a shot at significant public
financial support — I would do everything possible to up my game, even where
"aesthetics" (which often overlap with readability and usability) are
concerned. I understand that fixing LibreOffice Writer's horrible character
spacing may well be a Herculean task, but if wrongly displayed soft hyphens are
a relatively easy fix, I'd say it's worth attempting.

I'll tell you what: I've been using LibreOffice since version 4.x, and I don't
recall noticing the soft hyphen problem before. If it's a regression somewhere
along the line, knowing when it occurred might help you bug-fixers pinpoint how
it happened. I'm still trying to recover from a BRUTAL second round of Long
COVID, which inflicted a serious hit on my stamina and ability to concentrate.
Nonetheless, I'll try to start building some parallel installs of old versions
to regression-test the bug, and if I spot a regression point, I'll reopen the
bug. Again, I'm not at my best, so it could take a while.

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are the assignee for the bug.

Reply via email to