https://bugs.freedesktop.org/show_bug.cgi?id=80583

--- Comment #8 from Jacques Guilleron <guillero...@aol.com> ---
Hello Kevin,

Installed in a new profile, I don't reproduce the issue with LO 4.2.5.2 and
Windows 7 Home Premium.
> When you were generating ANOVA in D1, are you sure you are using A1:B100 as   
>  > data source? (not only a single cell?)
Yes. Dialog window at the beginning was made for that.
> I can 100% reproduce even I copy A1:B100 anywhere.
OK.
> Those numbers in A1:A100 were generated by using the "Edit - Fill - Random    
>  > Numbers".
If I copied them, it's mainly to have the same results with ANOVA.
> In fact, even the following simple numbers in A1:B2 will get the same ERR 509:
> 1,2
> 3,4
OK.
> There is no problem with Number1 and Number2 separated by comma. In calc, 
> formula both accepts "," and ";". For example, "=SUM(1,2)" and "=SUM(1;2)" 
> all > get the expected results.
I don't think so. "SUM(1,2)" give me "1,2", "SUM(1, 2)" give "Err:509" and
delete the comma, and "SUM(1;2)" give "3".
Anyway, for ANNOVA, changing the comma by semicolon give the result into the
formula of Total.
> The formula in E11 was not input manually, it was generated by "Data          
> > Statistics - Analysis of Variance". So even there was "input error", its 
> not > the user's fault.
Yes. You are right and that has to be fixed.
> However, the reality is that, there is no input error. (If you copy and paste 
> > the exact same formula within E11 to another cell, it get the expected      
>  > result, rather than ERR 508.)
If I do that, I get Err:501

regards,

Jacques

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are the assignee for the bug.
_______________________________________________
Libreoffice-bugs mailing list
Libreoffice-bugs@lists.freedesktop.org
http://lists.freedesktop.org/mailman/listinfo/libreoffice-bugs

Reply via email to