https://bugs.freedesktop.org/show_bug.cgi?id=80768
Rainer Bielefeld Retired <[email protected]> changed: What |Removed |Added ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Severity|normal |enhancement CC| |LibreOffice@bielefeldundbus | |s.de Summary|Other: things lost after |Cell ranges with the same |crash |Conditional Formatting | |should be consolidated to 1 | |range. --- Comment #16 from Rainer Bielefeld Retired <[email protected]> --- The report summery is concerning "things" with a "crash", but the "steps comic" seems not to show a crash? LibreOffice test with a little variation to Comment 12 1. Open Sample Document 2. menu {Format ► Conditional Formatting ► Manage}: There is a common CF for A1:B6 3. Close CF dialog 4. Select A1:A3 ► Drag and Drop to C4:C6 5. menu {Format ► Conditional Formatting ► Manage}: The result is that CF for A4:B6 still does exist, CF for B1:B3 still does exist, CF of A1:A3 has been moved together with contents to C4:C6 Everything ok! 6. Click Undo icon As Expected cell contents jumps back to A1:A3 7. menu {Format ► Conditional Formatting ► Manage}: CF A1:A6 from step 2 still / again does exist (minor problem: splitted into 2 ranges although A1:A3 and A4:A6 have the same CF) CF B1:B3 from step 2 still / again does exist CF B4:B6 from step 2 still / again does exist Everything as expected First LibreOffice test with a little variation to Comment 12 11. Open Sample Document 12. menu {Format ► Conditional Formatting ► Manage}: There is a common CF for A1:B6 13. Close CF dialog 14. Select A1:A3 ► Drag and Drop to B4:B6 15. menu {Format ► Conditional Formatting ► Manage}: The result is that CF for A4:B6 still does exist, CF for B1:B3 still does exist, CF of A1:A3 has been moved together with contents to B4:B6 Everything ok, only minor problem that LibO does not recognize that A4:A6 and B4:B6 have the same CF and that that range could be shown as one range A4:B6 with common CF 16. Click Undo icon As Expected cell contents jumps back to A1:A3 17. menu {Format ► Conditional Formatting ► Manage}: CF A1:B6 from step 2 still / again does exist Minor problem: splitted into 4 ranges although All cells A1:B6 have the same CF So CF is completely ok, but problem is that Range CF range A1:B6 has been devided / fragmented into 4 ranges My observations are the same as in Comment 12, but my conclusion is a little different. On a different wIN7 PC with LibreOffice 4.0.0 I found that {Format ► Manage} had a bug there: In step 17 CF for A1:A3 was destroyed and after adding a new CF for A1:A3 that was not shown in {Format ► Manage}. But that problem does no longer exist. So here I only see a possible enhancement: Libo should recognize if cell ranges with the same CF could be consolidated to 1 Cell range. Instead of continuing to try to find out what the reporter's real problem might have been bugs different to the summary I now created should be reported separately. @ign_christian You did not state clearly what of your observations you consider as a bug. Fragemntation of range with all the same CF or something else -- You are receiving this mail because: You are the assignee for the bug.
_______________________________________________ Libreoffice-bugs mailing list [email protected] http://lists.freedesktop.org/mailman/listinfo/libreoffice-bugs
