https://bugs.freedesktop.org/show_bug.cgi?id=82272
--- Comment #7 from Jay Philips <[email protected]> --- (In reply to comment #6) > Hi Jay, Hi Mirek, > The refreshed icon set is based on the Gnome icon set. This chart icon comes > straight from the Gnome icon for presentations (just scaled up a bit) and > fits the style of the refreshed set well. Yes, it's not flat, but the former > icon wasn't flat either and nor do any of the other new icons have a > completely flat appearance -- there are plenty of shadows and highlights in > the new icons and a some icons are tilted to show depth. Well i think that limiting the refreshed icon set on gnome's icon set is not a good approach, as it may be familiar for users of gnome but not for others. Maybe my use of the word "flat" isnt the right word, but all of the icons are front facing icons except for printer (front facing but tilted), currency (i think this may also needs a new icon - maybe fewer larger coins), and the current chart icon. The one you are suggesting has shines on it on both parts, while others icons may have a slight highlight on them. > Also note that icon symbol size is (and never should be) based on command > importance. Note that Bold and Italic are much smaller than the space > afforded to them, and that is a conscious design decision. I know that it doesnt depend on command importance, but i'm suggesting that there is ample space available to have it take up as much space as the drawing icon next to it, so that its easier to spot within the many available icons in the toolbars. > That said, I agree that the icon could be a bit better. I might work on it a > bit later. I was only recommending the use of the already available tango_testing icon as it fits well as its front facing and a good size. I personally like most of the original tango icon style found in 4.2 and dislike alot of the changes made to it, mainly the direct formatting buttons as they pretty much all look like they are bold and you cant even see the shadow behind the shadow icon in the sidebar. I wish there was a tango_original option that i could revert it back to in 4.3. -- You are receiving this mail because: You are the assignee for the bug.
_______________________________________________ Libreoffice-bugs mailing list [email protected] http://lists.freedesktop.org/mailman/listinfo/libreoffice-bugs
