https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=153465
--- Comment #8 from Sierk Bornemann <[email protected]> --- (In reply to steve from comment #7) > Sierk, thanks for your input which is appreciated. > > > which theme, which icons are more Mac-like, do fit better into the current > > macOS UI environment, do blend better with it? > > Obviously I have been asking this myself for quite some time and honestly > when looking at Pages, Number, Music, Mail and other Apple apps which mostly > follow their HIG, neither Sukapura, Sifr or Colibre feel very much mac like. +1 > Since Apple goes with monochrome icons, probably Sifr or breeze are closest. I am ambivalent on this: I find the Sifr icons too fat/thick, would therefore prefer the Breeze icons, which are finer/thinner, because of that, I can live with current default Breeze dark icon theme on macOS better than with Colibre. What about a look at Apples free to use Apple Developer: SF Symbols https://developer.apple.com/sf-symbols/ https://developer.apple.com/design/human-interface-guidelines/foundations/sf-symbols/ https://developer.apple.com/design/human-interface-guidelines/guidelines/overview ? Multicolor, Monocolor, b/w, SVG, etc. What about a new proposal: a _new_ theme, for normal and dark mode, using THESE Apple SF Symbols/icons and/or additionally icons, that are of their style, blend ideally with them, because they are of their same style and design language? If not, which ones are nearer at these Apple SF icons and blend better with them style-wise – Breeze or Sifr? Colibre and Sukapura seem to be NOT at all, on that we both seem to agree. > I don't have objections to stick with Sukapura, although I can't tell what > makes Sukapira very macOS like. Where on macOS can you find icons that are > even slightly similar to Sukapura? +1 > However without a dark mode variant it is not a good choice. +1 But as you can read, a dark mode Sukapura theme was not wanted, the poll's result is another than that. Unfortunately, I find. Is I understand Rizmut, Rizmut wanted to make the poll to have a votum to create a Sukapura dark theme, this votum didn't materialize, the votum wanted Breeze dark as dark theme on macOS (while sticking with Sukapura in normal mode). "Suboptimal" and in itself and on this particulary platform (macOS) inconsistent, I find, to say the least, to put it politely. > This is up to > Rizmut as they are doing the voluntary (afaik unpaid) work of maybe adding > Sukapura dark. Since they state "I have no strong preference here (macOS > icon theme) but the availability of Sukapura Dark version will not occur in > a short time". Or maybe money can be directed in that way in form of a > tender. But I don't make those calls. +1 LibreOffice UX Team, LibreOffice Design Team should set it as a topic, should discuss and make a decision, I think. -- You are receiving this mail because: You are the assignee for the bug.
