https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=157961

--- Comment #8 from William Friedman <[email protected]> ---
I wrote a long comment for bug 157784, but in the interim the bug/regression
was solved by (thankfully!) reverting the problematic patch. 

The issue of the ordering of the sheet tabs remains, however. Since, like
Mahmoud there, I use an LTR interface but work very frequently with RTL-only
and mixed LTR/RTL spreadsheets, I figured an additional opinion might be of
use.

The simplest and most elegant solution, IMO, would be to make this aspect of
the UI easily configurable, e.g., an option could be added, e.g., under "View"
there could be an option "Display Sheet Order" with two radio buttons "LTR" and
"RTL."

The default behavior could follow the user interface unless this option is
changed, although I can imagine two other solutions: 

1) Follow the directionality of the majority of the sheets (this fails if there
are an equal number of LTR and RTL sheets); 

2) The first time a sheet of different directionality than the UI is created, a
pop up could appear: "Switch direction of sheet order?" (A similar pop up could
also deal with the failure case of option 1.)

(Regarding Mahmoud's larger complaints about UI tinkering, I am reminded of the
lengthy discussion in bug 155494 regarding a change in cursor behavior that
many of those commenting thought was poorly-considered. Perhaps there needs to
be a "public comment" system for proposed UI changes in which users could give
their input and vote.)

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are the assignee for the bug.

Reply via email to