https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=156443

--- Comment #10 from Mike Kaganski <mikekagan...@hotmail.com> ---
(In reply to V Stuart Foote from comment #9)
> But don't the VK_NUMPAD[0-9] emit different scancodes to the VK_[0-9]? Hex
> values (and decimal) of 0x60 -- 0x69 (96-105), 0x30 -- 0x39 (48-57)
> respectively.  [1][2]

Indeed. We are able to disambiguate ~all keys on keyboard. If wanted, we can
also keep the numpad numbers for Alt-extended characters, and other numbers for
shortcuts. This still requires fixing bug 158112 (e.g., exactly this way:
making Alt+Number shortcuts only work for non-numpad numbers) first, as I
explained in comment 3.

> The 'EnableHexNumpad' flavor ALT codes maybe needing a bit more handling,
> but by that point our <Alt>+x toggle already services Unicode centric users.

EnableHexNumpad may be a separate issue, if needed. I mentioned it here, but
with a note that "a follow-up enhancement could be filed for that". So it may
be excluded from consideration here.

However, I would think that Alt+NonNumpadNumber shortcut would still be
confusing. Also, listing the Alt+Number in customization provokes for using it;
and people who will try will *mostly* complain that it doesn't work: they would
expect numpad numbers to do what they expect from the shortcut, and see it
doesn't (because it would be used for Alt+Numpad Number extended character
function).

I am strongly in favor of removing Alt+Number as an assignable key combination
on Windows, completely.

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are the assignee for the bug.

Reply via email to