Hi guys,
On Wed, 2012-02-29 at 15:28 +0100, Lubos Lunak wrote:
> First, so that we have some numbers, libmswordlo.so debug build, but compiled
> with -O2 -g0 :
So - I did some more analysis, and re-compiled all of LibreOffice both
with and without the attached patch - analysing all 287 shared libraries
we get:
$ du -b -c ../../without-stripped/program/*.so | tail
...
171373684 total
$ du -b -c ../../with-stripped/program/*.so | tail
...
174692100 total
$
ie. we have as a lower bound a 1.8% size saving. I expect that to grow
as we start to LTO - as we can finally propagate the fact that methods
don't throw exceptions across modules, and across libraries.
Now - the immediate, and expected riposte is that ~2% of our size is
insignificant ( to go along with the 3% of our CPU time at startup
parsing labels we mostly don't need ;-). Personally, I don't think the
approach of ignoring any efficiency win as insignificant if it is less
than 10% across a code-base of our size is sustainable in the long
term :-) the more we ignore the more it adds up.
So here are the facts, correct me if I'm wrong:
* often std::bad_alloc is not handled, making the program
abort, the exception is not caught by main - there is no
autosave and data is lost - ie. a SEGV would be preferable.
* often we fail to emit std::bad_alloc in out of memory
conditions, cf. sal/inc/rtl/allocator.hxx etc. etc.
* it is unarguably the case that there is no consistent
bad_alloc handling, it is random, ill thought through and
anything less than aborting that complete document load/save/
calculate operation will almost certainly lead to (silent)
data loss / document errors.
* the user experience of: "we're out of memory, by the way we
prolly lost some of your document, please try to save,
re-start compare the data etc." is insignificantly less
painful than taking a crash.
* in cases where we have a reasonable expectation of an
allocation failing and the ability to actually do something
meaningful: loading images perhaps, where we could swapout
other images, we can (and do) call the allocation ourself
and handle return values.
* IMHO for everything else, we just waste 2% of our size, and
some CPU cost for no good reason at all, and doubly so for
the case of OUString("foo") const-strings that we allocate
internally that cannot be that large.
Ergo, I suggest we discuss this at the ESC tomorrow, with a view to a
pragmatic, top-to-bottom solution that actually has a chance of working
well.
I've added it to the agenda.
I also attach the git hash I built from, my config options, the size of
all the .so's installed etc.
All the best,
Michael.
--
michael.me...@suse.com <><, Pseudo Engineer, itinerant idiot
diff --git a/sal/inc/rtl/byteseq.hxx b/sal/inc/rtl/byteseq.hxx
index 852670e..d1154ff 100644
--- a/sal/inc/rtl/byteseq.hxx
+++ b/sal/inc/rtl/byteseq.hxx
@@ -33,7 +33,7 @@
#include <rtl/alloc.h>
#include <rtl/memory.h>
-#if ! defined EXCEPTIONS_OFF
+#if ! defined SAL_EXCEPTIONS_OFF
#include <new>
#endif
@@ -64,7 +64,7 @@ inline ByteSequence::ByteSequence( const sal_Int8 * pElements, sal_Int32 len )
: _pSequence( 0 )
{
::rtl_byte_sequence_constructFromArray( &_pSequence, pElements, len );
-#if ! defined EXCEPTIONS_OFF
+#if ! defined SAL_EXCEPTIONS_OFF
if (_pSequence == 0)
throw ::std::bad_alloc();
#endif
@@ -74,7 +74,7 @@ inline ByteSequence::ByteSequence( sal_Int32 len, enum __ByteSequence_NoDefault
: _pSequence( 0 )
{
::rtl_byte_sequence_constructNoDefault( &_pSequence, len );
-#if ! defined EXCEPTIONS_OFF
+#if ! defined SAL_EXCEPTIONS_OFF
if (_pSequence == 0)
throw ::std::bad_alloc();
#endif
@@ -89,7 +89,7 @@ inline ByteSequence::ByteSequence( sal_Int32 len )
: _pSequence( 0 )
{
::rtl_byte_sequence_construct( &_pSequence, len );
-#if ! defined EXCEPTIONS_OFF
+#if ! defined SAL_EXCEPTIONS_OFF
if (_pSequence == 0)
throw ::std::bad_alloc();
#endif
@@ -114,7 +114,7 @@ inline sal_Bool ByteSequence::operator == ( const ByteSequence & rSeq ) const SA
inline sal_Int8 * ByteSequence::getArray()
{
::rtl_byte_sequence_reference2One( &_pSequence );
-#if ! defined EXCEPTIONS_OFF
+#if ! defined SAL_EXCEPTIONS_OFF
if (_pSequence == 0)
throw ::std::bad_alloc();
#endif
@@ -124,7 +124,7 @@ inline sal_Int8 * ByteSequence::getArray()
inline void ByteSequence::realloc( sal_Int32 nSize )
{
::rtl_byte_sequence_realloc( &_pSequence, nSize );
-#if ! defined EXCEPTIONS_OFF
+#if ! defined SAL_EXCEPTIONS_OFF
if (_pSequence == 0)
throw ::std::bad_alloc();
#endif
diff --git a/sal/inc/rtl/string.hxx b/sal/inc/rtl/string.hxx
index e879f32..d10499a 100644
--- a/sal/inc/rtl/string.hxx
+++ b/sal/inc/rtl/string.hxx
@@ -39,7 +39,7 @@
#include <rtl/string.h>
#include "sal/log.hxx"
-#if !defined EXCEPTIONS_OFF
+#if !defined SAL_EXCEPTIONS_OFF
#include <new>
#endif
@@ -186,8 +186,8 @@ public:
pData = 0;
rtl_uString2String( &pData, value, length, encoding, convertFlags );
if (pData == 0) {
-#if defined EXCEPTIONS_OFF
- SAL_WARN("sal", "std::bad_alloc but EXCEPTIONS_OFF");
+#if defined SAL_EXCEPTIONS_OFF
+ SAL_WARN("sal", "std::bad_alloc but SAL_EXCEPTIONS_OFF");
#else
throw std::bad_alloc();
#endif
diff --git a/sal/inc/rtl/ustring.hxx b/sal/inc/rtl/ustring.hxx
index 27eb865..fd2c023 100644
--- a/sal/inc/rtl/ustring.hxx
+++ b/sal/inc/rtl/ustring.hxx
@@ -39,7 +39,7 @@
#include <rtl/memory.h>
#include "sal/log.hxx"
-#if defined EXCEPTIONS_OFF
+#if defined SAL_EXCEPTIONS_OFF
#include <stdlib.h>
#else
#include <new>
@@ -183,8 +183,8 @@ public:
pData = 0;
rtl_string2UString( &pData, literal, N - 1, RTL_TEXTENCODING_UTF8, OSTRING_TO_OUSTRING_CVTFLAGS );
if (pData == 0) {
-#if defined EXCEPTIONS_OFF
- SAL_WARN("sal", "std::bad_alloc but EXCEPTIONS_OFF");
+#if defined SAL_EXCEPTIONS_OFF
+ SAL_WARN("sal", "std::bad_alloc but SAL_EXCEPTIONS_OFF");
#else
throw std::bad_alloc();
#endif
@@ -247,8 +247,8 @@ public:
pData = 0;
rtl_string2UString( &pData, value, length, encoding, convertFlags );
if (pData == 0) {
-#if defined EXCEPTIONS_OFF
- SAL_WARN("sal", "std::bad_alloc but EXCEPTIONS_OFF");
+#if defined SAL_EXCEPTIONS_OFF
+ SAL_WARN("sal", "std::bad_alloc but SAL_EXCEPTIONS_OFF");
#else
throw std::bad_alloc();
#endif
@@ -277,7 +277,7 @@ public:
{
rtl_uString_newFromCodePoints(&pData, codePoints, codePointCount);
if (pData == NULL) {
-#if defined EXCEPTIONS_OFF
+#if defined SAL_EXCEPTIONS_OFF
abort();
#else
throw std::bad_alloc();
@@ -1536,8 +1536,8 @@ public:
rtl_uString * pNew = 0;
rtl_uString_intern( &pNew, pData );
if (pNew == 0) {
-#if defined EXCEPTIONS_OFF
- SAL_WARN("sal", "std::bad_alloc but EXCEPTIONS_OFF");
+#if defined SAL_EXCEPTIONS_OFF
+ SAL_WARN("sal", "std::bad_alloc but SAL_EXCEPTIONS_OFF");
#else
throw std::bad_alloc();
#endif
@@ -1579,8 +1579,8 @@ public:
rtl_uString_internConvert( &pNew, value, length, encoding,
convertFlags, pInfo );
if (pNew == 0) {
-#if defined EXCEPTIONS_OFF
- SAL_WARN("sal", "std::bad_alloc but EXCEPTIONS_OFF");
+#if defined SAL_EXCEPTIONS_OFF
+ SAL_WARN("sal", "std::bad_alloc but SAL_EXCEPTIONS_OFF");
#else
throw std::bad_alloc();
#endif
diff --git a/sal/inc/sal/mathconf.h b/sal/inc/sal/mathconf.h
index 1e4b11b..3abb09a 100644
--- a/sal/inc/sal/mathconf.h
+++ b/sal/inc/sal/mathconf.h
@@ -52,7 +52,7 @@ extern "C" {
execution, "a programmer can safely assume default modes (or be unaware of
them)" (7.6/2, footnote 161 of the August 3, 1998 draft of C99). Reportedly,
on Windows there are printer drivers that switch on exceptions. To avoid
- problems, the SAL_MATH_FPEXCEPTIONS_OFF macro can be used to explicitly
+ problems, the SAL_MATH_FPSAL_EXCEPTIONS_OFF macro can be used to explicitly
switch off exceptions (on Windows).
*/
#if defined WNT
diff --git a/solenv/gbuild/platform/com_GCC_defs.mk b/solenv/gbuild/platform/com_GCC_defs.mk
index fb032ad..07fd949 100644
--- a/solenv/gbuild/platform/com_GCC_defs.mk
+++ b/solenv/gbuild/platform/com_GCC_defs.mk
@@ -118,11 +118,13 @@ endif
gb_LinkTarget_EXCEPTIONFLAGS := \
-DEXCEPTIONS_ON \
+ -DSAL_EXCEPTIONS_OFF \
-fexceptions \
-fno-enforce-eh-specs \
gb_LinkTarget_NOEXCEPTIONFLAGS := \
-DEXCEPTIONS_OFF \
+ -DSAL_EXCEPTIONS_OFF \
-fno-exceptions \
diff --git a/solenv/inc/settings.mk b/solenv/inc/settings.mk
index bf5dcab..ece1b3e 100644
--- a/solenv/inc/settings.mk
+++ b/solenv/inc/settings.mk
@@ -1112,6 +1112,7 @@ GLOBAL_EXCEPTIONS_FLAGS+=-DEXCEPTIONS_ON
GLOBAL_EXCEPTIONS_FLAGS+=$(CFLAGS_NO_EXCEPTIONS)
GLOBAL_EXCEPTIONS_FLAGS+=-DEXCEPTIONS_OFF
.ENDIF
+GLOBAL_EXCEPTIONS_FLAGS+=-DSAL_EXCEPTIONS_OFF
# used if an object appears in the EXCEPTIONSFILES list
# see also rules.mk
LOCAL_EXCEPTIONS_FLAGS+=$(CFLAGSEXCEPTIONS)
compiled from commit:
commit 5279616d50b0394e8ec6d8e2109471ca649412b7
Author: Bjoern Michaelsen <bjoern.michael...@canonical.com>
Date: Tue Feb 28 14:29:06 2012 +0100
lp#562027: fix logout with quickstarter
on ia32 ...
--with-num-cpus=16
--with-max-jobs=16
--without-fonts
--enable-gtk3
--with-system-cairo
--enable-mergelibs
--enable-icecream
--enable-ext-pdfimport
--enable-kde
--enable-kde4
--enable-ext-scripting-beanshell
--enable-ext-scripting-javascript
--enable-ext-wiki-publisher
--enable-ext-report-builder
--enable-ext-presenter-minimizer
--enable-ext-presenter-console
--enable-ext-pdfimport
--enable-ext-nlpsolver
--enable-ext-postgresql-sdbc
--with-system-postgresql
* Do a build / install with and without exceptions in sal ...
* interesting pointers
* sal/inc/rtl/allocator.hxx
+ doesn't throw ::std::bad_alloc() ...
With string exceptions:
104584 ../../with-stripped/program/basprov.uno.so
511400 ../../with-stripped/program/cairocanvas.uno.so
59088 ../../with-stripped/program/canvasfactory.uno.so
55068 ../../with-stripped/program/cmdmail.uno.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/configmgr.uno.so
38524 ../../with-stripped/program/desktopbe1.uno.so
149628 ../../with-stripped/program/dlgprov.uno.so
210908 ../../with-stripped/program/expwrap.uno.so
194468 ../../with-stripped/program/fastsax.uno.so
13932 ../../with-stripped/program/fpicker.uno.so
55320 ../../with-stripped/program/fps_kde4.uno.so
67556 ../../with-stripped/program/fps_kde.uno.so
265320 ../../with-stripped/program/fps_office.uno.so
137184 ../../with-stripped/program/fsstorage.uno.so
46908 ../../with-stripped/program/gconfbe1.uno.so
92196 ../../with-stripped/program/hatchwindowfactory.uno.so
1528468 ../../with-stripped/program/i18npool.uno.so
42712 ../../with-stripped/program/i18nsearch.uno.so
42736 ../../with-stripped/program/kde4be1.uno.so
42728 ../../with-stripped/program/kdebe1.uno.so
59180 ../../with-stripped/program/ldapbe2.uno.so
149952 ../../with-stripped/program/libabplo.so
1012152 ../../with-stripped/program/libacclo.so
137096 ../../with-stripped/program/libanalysislo.so
133304 ../../with-stripped/program/libanimcorelo.so
47004 ../../with-stripped/program/libavmediagst.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libavmedialo.so
1160396 ../../with-stripped/program/libbasctllo.so
988824 ../../with-stripped/program/libbasebmplo.so
505664 ../../with-stripped/program/libbasegfxlo.so
347160 ../../with-stripped/program/libbiblo.so
206604 ../../with-stripped/program/libcached1.so
265032 ../../with-stripped/program/libcalclo.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libcanvastoolslo.so
539640 ../../with-stripped/program/libcdrimportlo.so
2249040 ../../with-stripped/program/libchartcontrollerlo.so
938288 ../../with-stripped/program/libchartmodello.so
990924 ../../with-stripped/program/libcharttoolslo.so
830656 ../../with-stripped/program/libchartviewlo.so
1840572 ../../with-stripped/program/libclucene.so
1553740 ../../with-stripped/program/libcollator_data.so
1229320 ../../with-stripped/program/libcomphelpgcc3.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libcppcanvaslo.so
182068 ../../with-stripped/program/libctllo.so
3365188 ../../with-stripped/program/libcuilo.so
42772 ../../with-stripped/program/libdatelo.so
1599948 ../../with-stripped/program/libdb-4.7.so
2104268 ../../with-stripped/program/libdbalo.so
413108 ../../with-stripped/program/libdbaselo.so
328692 ../../with-stripped/program/libdbaxmllo.so
211356 ../../with-stripped/program/libdbmmlo.so
215260 ../../with-stripped/program/libdbplo.so
120844 ../../with-stripped/program/libdbpool2.so
1547948 ../../with-stripped/program/libdbtoolslo.so
3589784 ../../with-stripped/program/libdbulo.so
396476 ../../with-stripped/program/libdeploymentgui.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libdeploymentmisclo.so
724584 ../../with-stripped/program/libdeployment.so
9740 ../../with-stripped/program/libdesktop_detectorlo.so
1054028 ../../with-stripped/program/libdict_ja.so
2266444 ../../with-stripped/program/libdict_zh.so
706324 ../../with-stripped/program/libdoctoklo.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libdrawinglayerlo.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libeditenglo.so
17984 ../../with-stripped/program/libegilo.so
378936 ../../with-stripped/program/libembobj.so
231336 ../../with-stripped/program/libemboleobj.so
59268 ../../with-stripped/program/libemelo.so
9696 ../../with-stripped/program/libepblo.so
9696 ../../with-stripped/program/libepglo.so
9696 ../../with-stripped/program/libepplo.so
75944 ../../with-stripped/program/libepslo.so
51120 ../../with-stripped/program/libeptlo.so
9632 ../../with-stripped/program/liberalo.so
13852 ../../with-stripped/program/libetilo.so
67368 ../../with-stripped/program/libevtattlo.so
9708 ../../with-stripped/program/libexplo.so
75736 ../../with-stripped/program/libfileacc.so
589084 ../../with-stripped/program/libfilelo.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libfilterconfiglo.so
199404 ../../with-stripped/program/libflashlo.so
269212 ../../with-stripped/program/libflatlo.so
128936 ../../with-stripped/program/libforlo.so
162132 ../../with-stripped/program/libforuilo.so
284300 ../../with-stripped/program/libfreebl3.so
2262452 ../../with-stripped/program/libfrmlo.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libfwelo.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libfwilo.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libfwklo.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libfwllo.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libfwmlo.so
51084 ../../with-stripped/program/libguesslanglo.so
206884 ../../with-stripped/program/libhelplinkerlo.so
286280 ../../with-stripped/program/libhsqldb.so
552108 ../../with-stripped/program/libhwplo.so
83956 ../../with-stripped/program/libhyphenlo.so
26200 ../../with-stripped/program/libi18nisolang1gcc3.so
26256 ../../with-stripped/program/libi18npaperlo.so
30240 ../../with-stripped/program/libi18nregexplo.so
65168 ../../with-stripped/program/libi18nutilgcc3.so
9704 ../../with-stripped/program/libicdlo.so
108352 ../../with-stripped/program/libicglo.so
79604 ../../with-stripped/program/libidxlo.so
51024 ../../with-stripped/program/libimelo.so
533964 ../../with-stripped/program/libindex_data.so
9668 ../../with-stripped/program/libipblo.so
17940 ../../with-stripped/program/libipdlo.so
26356 ../../with-stripped/program/libipslo.so
42704 ../../with-stripped/program/libiptlo.so
9644 ../../with-stripped/program/libipxlo.so
9628 ../../with-stripped/program/libiralo.so
13748 ../../with-stripped/program/libitglo.so
34376 ../../with-stripped/program/libitilo.so
404056 ../../with-stripped/program/libjdbclo.so
59192 ../../with-stripped/program/libkab1.so
281440 ../../with-stripped/program/libkabdrv1.so
207524 ../../with-stripped/program/libldap50.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/liblnglo.so
79864 ../../with-stripped/program/liblnthlo.so
172340 ../../with-stripped/program/liblocaledata_en.so
171180 ../../with-stripped/program/liblocaledata_es.so
1151412 ../../with-stripped/program/liblocaledata_euro.so
1418116 ../../with-stripped/program/liblocaledata_others.so
125140 ../../with-stripped/program/libloglo.so
625236 ../../with-stripped/program/liblpsolve55.so
1092612 ../../with-stripped/program/liblwpftlo.so
38620 ../../with-stripped/program/libmcnttype.so
32544740 ../../with-stripped/program/libmergedlo.so
479480 ../../with-stripped/program/libmozabdrvlo.so
38608 ../../with-stripped/program/libmozablo.so
772432 ../../with-stripped/program/libmozjs.so
75400 ../../with-stripped/program/libmozz.so
685532 ../../with-stripped/program/libmsfilterlo.so
396256 ../../with-stripped/program/libmsgbaseutil.so
1755448 ../../with-stripped/program/libmswordlo.so
482224 ../../with-stripped/program/libmsworkslo.so
195080 ../../with-stripped/program/libmysqllo.so
1482060 ../../with-stripped/program/libneon.so
22064 ../../with-stripped/program/libnpsoplugin.so
237548 ../../with-stripped/program/libnspr4.so
1312556 ../../with-stripped/program/libnss3.so
409668 ../../with-stripped/program/libnssckbi.so
161632 ../../with-stripped/program/libnssdbm3.so
108368 ../../with-stripped/program/libnssutil3.so
502484 ../../with-stripped/program/libodbcbaselo.so
34452 ../../with-stripped/program/libodbclo.so
26288 ../../with-stripped/program/libodfflatxmllo.so
46900 ../../with-stripped/program/liboffacclo.so
5456 ../../with-stripped/program/libofficebeanlo.so
8523936 ../../with-stripped/program/libooxlo.so
1931904 ../../with-stripped/program/libooxmllo.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libpackage2.so
1225760 ../../with-stripped/program/libpcrlo.so
211768 ../../with-stripped/program/libpdffilterlo.so
63300 ../../with-stripped/program/libplacewarelo.so
17912 ../../with-stripped/program/libplc4.so
13784 ../../with-stripped/program/libplds4.so
219836 ../../with-stripped/program/libpllo.so
18004 ../../with-stripped/program/libprldap50.so
55032 ../../with-stripped/program/libprotocolhandlerlo.so
244800 ../../with-stripped/program/libpyuno.so
22236 ../../with-stripped/program/libqstart_gtklo.so
153224 ../../with-stripped/program/librecentfile.so
75784 ../../with-stripped/program/libreslo.so
575200 ../../with-stripped/program/libresourcemodello.so
1085532 ../../with-stripped/program/librptlo.so
1091952 ../../with-stripped/program/librptuilo.so
378808 ../../with-stripped/program/librptxmllo.so
318928 ../../with-stripped/program/librtftoklo.so
104308 ../../with-stripped/program/libsaxlo.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libsblo.so
47036 ../../with-stripped/program/libscdlo.so
2535372 ../../with-stripped/program/libscfiltlo.so
10032780 ../../with-stripped/program/libsclo.so
117068 ../../with-stripped/program/libscnlo.so
174292 ../../with-stripped/program/libscriptframe.so
659612 ../../with-stripped/program/libscuilo.so
67384 ../../with-stripped/program/libsdbc2.so
100344 ../../with-stripped/program/libsdbtlo.so
47084 ../../with-stripped/program/libsddlo.so
585944 ../../with-stripped/program/libsdfiltlo.so
5755652 ../../with-stripped/program/libsdlo.so
483604 ../../with-stripped/program/libsduilo.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libsfxlo.so
38812 ../../with-stripped/program/libsmdlo.so
170968 ../../with-stripped/program/libsmime3.so
944464 ../../with-stripped/program/libsmlo.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libsofficeapp.so
244204 ../../with-stripped/program/libsoftokn3.so
55148 ../../with-stripped/program/libsolverlo.so
352296 ../../with-stripped/program/libsotlo.so
232148 ../../with-stripped/program/libspalo.so
388628 ../../with-stripped/program/libspelllo.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libspllo.so
18128 ../../with-stripped/program/libspl_unxlo.so
483708 ../../with-stripped/program/libsqlite3.so
124660 ../../with-stripped/program/libsrtrs1.so
215892 ../../with-stripped/program/libssl3.so
716036 ../../with-stripped/program/libsvgfilterlo.so
979088 ../../with-stripped/program/libsvllo.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libsvtlo.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libsvxcorelo.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libsvxlo.so
55320 ../../with-stripped/program/libswdlo.so
12109100 ../../with-stripped/program/libswlo.so
2186104 ../../with-stripped/program/libswuilo.so
121440 ../../with-stripped/program/libt602filterlo.so
230732 ../../with-stripped/program/libtextconv_dict.so
108664 ../../with-stripped/program/libtextconversiondlgslo.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libtklo.so
571968 ../../with-stripped/program/libtllo.so
227124 ../../with-stripped/program/libtvhlp1.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libucb1.so
432200 ../../with-stripped/program/libucbhelper4gcc3.so
329856 ../../with-stripped/program/libucpchelp1.so
350748 ../../with-stripped/program/libucpdav1.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libucpfile1.so
178216 ../../with-stripped/program/libucpftp1.so
235528 ../../with-stripped/program/libucphier1.so
190456 ../../with-stripped/program/libucppkg1.so
129164 ../../with-stripped/program/libunopkgapp.so
170332 ../../with-stripped/program/libunordflo.so
449808 ../../with-stripped/program/libunoxmllo.so
63484 ../../with-stripped/program/libupdatecheckuilo.so
1022336 ../../with-stripped/program/libutllo.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libuuilo.so
646380 ../../with-stripped/program/libvbahelperlo.so
4648056 ../../with-stripped/program/libvcllo.so
516688 ../../with-stripped/program/libvclplug_genlo.so
495984 ../../with-stripped/program/libvclplug_gtk3lo.so
471224 ../../with-stripped/program/libvclplug_gtklo.so
80160 ../../with-stripped/program/libvclplug_kde4lo.so
71804 ../../with-stripped/program/libvclplug_kdelo.so
92308 ../../with-stripped/program/libvclplug_svplo.so
764940 ../../with-stripped/program/libvisioimportlo.so
1179504 ../../with-stripped/program/libwpftlo.so
1056516 ../../with-stripped/program/libwpgimportlo.so
79880 ../../with-stripped/program/libwriterfilterlo.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libxcrlo.so
55104 ../../with-stripped/program/libxmlfalo.so
34544 ../../with-stripped/program/libxmlfdlo.so
281464 ../../with-stripped/program/libxmlsecurity.so
329804 ../../with-stripped/program/libxoflo.so
0 ../../with-stripped/program/libxolo.so
116888 ../../with-stripped/program/libxpcom_compat.so
779308 ../../with-stripped/program/libxpcom_core.so
13836 ../../with-stripped/program/libxpcom.so
133312 ../../with-stripped/program/libxsec_fw.so
704016 ../../with-stripped/program/libxsec_xmlsec.so
264764 ../../with-stripped/program/libxsltdlglo.so
108688 ../../with-stripped/program/libxsltfilterlo.so
534756 ../../with-stripped/program/libxstor.so
34464 ../../with-stripped/program/localebe1.uno.so
59364 ../../with-stripped/program/migrationoo2.uno.so
51084 ../../with-stripped/program/migrationoo3.uno.so
355116 ../../with-stripped/program/msforms.uno.so
34556 ../../with-stripped/program/mtfrenderer.uno.so
126248 ../../with-stripped/program/OGLTrans.uno.so
108468 ../../with-stripped/program/passwordcontainer.uno.so
708376 ../../with-stripped/program/postgresql-sdbc-impl.uno.so
55004 ../../with-stripped/program/postgresql-sdbc.uno.so
26376 ../../with-stripped/program/pythonloader.uno.so
5416 ../../with-stripped/program/pyuno.so
55096 ../../with-stripped/program/simplecanvas.uno.so
1428812 ../../with-stripped/program/slideshow.uno.so
141340 ../../with-stripped/program/stringresource.uno.so
38640 ../../with-stripped/program/syssh.uno.so
116724 ../../with-stripped/program/ucpcmis1.uno.so
26316 ../../with-stripped/program/ucpexpand1.uno.so
75656 ../../with-stripped/program/ucpext.uno.so
124980 ../../with-stripped/program/ucpgvfs1.uno.so
272756 ../../with-stripped/program/ucptdoc1.uno.so
67432 ../../with-stripped/program/updatefeed.uno.so
108616 ../../with-stripped/program/vbaevents.uno.so
1796536 ../../with-stripped/program/vbaobj.uno.so
1283500 ../../with-stripped/program/vbaswobj.uno.so
552460 ../../with-stripped/program/vclcanvas.uno.so
174692100 total
Without Exceptions
100484 ../../without-stripped/program/basprov.uno.so
503204 ../../without-stripped/program/cairocanvas.uno.so
54988 ../../without-stripped/program/canvasfactory.uno.so
50968 ../../without-stripped/program/cmdmail.uno.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/configmgr.uno.so
34424 ../../without-stripped/program/desktopbe1.uno.so
137336 ../../without-stripped/program/dlgprov.uno.so
206804 ../../without-stripped/program/expwrap.uno.so
190364 ../../without-stripped/program/fastsax.uno.so
13932 ../../without-stripped/program/fpicker.uno.so
51216 ../../without-stripped/program/fps_kde4.uno.so
63452 ../../without-stripped/program/fps_kde.uno.so
261220 ../../without-stripped/program/fps_office.uno.so
124896 ../../without-stripped/program/fsstorage.uno.so
42804 ../../without-stripped/program/gconfbe1.uno.so
84000 ../../without-stripped/program/hatchwindowfactory.uno.so
1503896 ../../without-stripped/program/i18npool.uno.so
42708 ../../without-stripped/program/i18nsearch.uno.so
42728 ../../without-stripped/program/kde4be1.uno.so
42720 ../../without-stripped/program/kdebe1.uno.so
55080 ../../without-stripped/program/ldapbe2.uno.so
145852 ../../without-stripped/program/libabplo.so
991668 ../../without-stripped/program/libacclo.so
128900 ../../without-stripped/program/libanalysislo.so
129204 ../../without-stripped/program/libanimcorelo.so
47004 ../../without-stripped/program/libavmediagst.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libavmedialo.so
1131720 ../../without-stripped/program/libbasctllo.so
988824 ../../without-stripped/program/libbasebmplo.so
505664 ../../without-stripped/program/libbasegfxlo.so
338964 ../../without-stripped/program/libbiblo.so
198408 ../../without-stripped/program/libcached1.so
252740 ../../without-stripped/program/libcalclo.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libcanvastoolslo.so
535540 ../../without-stripped/program/libcdrimportlo.so
2171212 ../../without-stripped/program/libchartcontrollerlo.so
901424 ../../without-stripped/program/libchartmodello.so
954056 ../../without-stripped/program/libcharttoolslo.so
801980 ../../without-stripped/program/libchartviewlo.so
1840572 ../../without-stripped/program/libclucene.so
1553740 ../../without-stripped/program/libcollator_data.so
1176072 ../../without-stripped/program/libcomphelpgcc3.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libcppcanvaslo.so
177968 ../../without-stripped/program/libctllo.so
3328324 ../../without-stripped/program/libcuilo.so
38668 ../../without-stripped/program/libdatelo.so
1599948 ../../without-stripped/program/libdb-4.7.so
2034636 ../../without-stripped/program/libdbalo.so
413108 ../../without-stripped/program/libdbaselo.so
312308 ../../without-stripped/program/libdbaxmllo.so
207260 ../../without-stripped/program/libdbmmlo.so
207068 ../../without-stripped/program/libdbplo.so
112648 ../../without-stripped/program/libdbpool2.so
1535660 ../../without-stripped/program/libdbtoolslo.so
3520152 ../../without-stripped/program/libdbulo.so
384188 ../../without-stripped/program/libdeploymentgui.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libdeploymentmisclo.so
683624 ../../without-stripped/program/libdeployment.so
9732 ../../without-stripped/program/libdesktop_detectorlo.so
1054028 ../../without-stripped/program/libdict_ja.so
2266444 ../../without-stripped/program/libdict_zh.so
702228 ../../without-stripped/program/libdoctoklo.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libdrawinglayerlo.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libeditenglo.so
17984 ../../without-stripped/program/libegilo.so
362552 ../../without-stripped/program/libembobj.so
231336 ../../without-stripped/program/libemboleobj.so
55164 ../../without-stripped/program/libemelo.so
9696 ../../without-stripped/program/libepblo.so
9696 ../../without-stripped/program/libepglo.so
9696 ../../without-stripped/program/libepplo.so
75936 ../../without-stripped/program/libepslo.so
51112 ../../without-stripped/program/libeptlo.so
9632 ../../without-stripped/program/liberalo.so
13852 ../../without-stripped/program/libetilo.so
63264 ../../without-stripped/program/libevtattlo.so
9708 ../../without-stripped/program/libexplo.so
67536 ../../without-stripped/program/libfileacc.so
589084 ../../without-stripped/program/libfilelo.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libfilterconfiglo.so
191208 ../../without-stripped/program/libflashlo.so
269212 ../../without-stripped/program/libflatlo.so
124836 ../../without-stripped/program/libforlo.so
162132 ../../without-stripped/program/libforuilo.so
284300 ../../without-stripped/program/libfreebl3.so
2209204 ../../without-stripped/program/libfrmlo.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libfwelo.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libfwilo.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libfwklo.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libfwllo.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libfwmlo.so
51084 ../../without-stripped/program/libguesslanglo.so
206888 ../../without-stripped/program/libhelplinkerlo.so
273992 ../../without-stripped/program/libhsqldb.so
552100 ../../without-stripped/program/libhwplo.so
79856 ../../without-stripped/program/libhyphenlo.so
26192 ../../without-stripped/program/libi18nisolang1gcc3.so
26252 ../../without-stripped/program/libi18npaperlo.so
30232 ../../without-stripped/program/libi18nregexplo.so
65164 ../../without-stripped/program/libi18nutilgcc3.so
9704 ../../without-stripped/program/libicdlo.so
104252 ../../without-stripped/program/libicglo.so
79604 ../../without-stripped/program/libidxlo.so
51024 ../../without-stripped/program/libimelo.so
533964 ../../without-stripped/program/libindex_data.so
9668 ../../without-stripped/program/libipblo.so
17940 ../../without-stripped/program/libipdlo.so
26348 ../../without-stripped/program/libipslo.so
42704 ../../without-stripped/program/libiptlo.so
9644 ../../without-stripped/program/libipxlo.so
9628 ../../without-stripped/program/libiralo.so
13748 ../../without-stripped/program/libitglo.so
34376 ../../without-stripped/program/libitilo.so
395864 ../../without-stripped/program/libjdbclo.so
50992 ../../without-stripped/program/libkab1.so
273248 ../../without-stripped/program/libkabdrv1.so
207524 ../../without-stripped/program/libldap50.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/liblnglo.so
75764 ../../without-stripped/program/liblnthlo.so
172340 ../../without-stripped/program/liblocaledata_en.so
171180 ../../without-stripped/program/liblocaledata_es.so
1151412 ../../without-stripped/program/liblocaledata_euro.so
1418116 ../../without-stripped/program/liblocaledata_others.so
116944 ../../without-stripped/program/libloglo.so
625236 ../../without-stripped/program/liblpsolve55.so
1088512 ../../without-stripped/program/liblwpftlo.so
34520 ../../without-stripped/program/libmcnttype.so
31778788 ../../without-stripped/program/libmergedlo.so
463092 ../../without-stripped/program/libmozabdrvlo.so
38604 ../../without-stripped/program/libmozablo.so
772432 ../../without-stripped/program/libmozjs.so
75400 ../../without-stripped/program/libmozz.so
673240 ../../without-stripped/program/libmsfilterlo.so
396256 ../../without-stripped/program/libmsgbaseutil.so
1739060 ../../without-stripped/program/libmswordlo.so
478124 ../../without-stripped/program/libmsworkslo.so
182792 ../../without-stripped/program/libmysqllo.so
1482060 ../../without-stripped/program/libneon.so
22064 ../../without-stripped/program/libnpsoplugin.so
237548 ../../without-stripped/program/libnspr4.so
1312556 ../../without-stripped/program/libnss3.so
409668 ../../without-stripped/program/libnssckbi.so
161632 ../../without-stripped/program/libnssdbm3.so
108368 ../../without-stripped/program/libnssutil3.so
490192 ../../without-stripped/program/libodbcbaselo.so
30344 ../../without-stripped/program/libodbclo.so
22188 ../../without-stripped/program/libodfflatxmllo.so
42796 ../../without-stripped/program/liboffacclo.so
5456 ../../without-stripped/program/libofficebeanlo.so
8351904 ../../without-stripped/program/libooxlo.so
1907324 ../../without-stripped/program/libooxmllo.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libpackage2.so
1188892 ../../without-stripped/program/libpcrlo.so
203572 ../../without-stripped/program/libpdffilterlo.so
59200 ../../without-stripped/program/libplacewarelo.so
17912 ../../without-stripped/program/libplc4.so
13784 ../../without-stripped/program/libplds4.so
211640 ../../without-stripped/program/libpllo.so
18004 ../../without-stripped/program/libprldap50.so
46832 ../../without-stripped/program/libprotocolhandlerlo.so
236608 ../../without-stripped/program/libpyuno.so
22232 ../../without-stripped/program/libqstart_gtklo.so
149128 ../../without-stripped/program/librecentfile.so
71684 ../../without-stripped/program/libreslo.so
575200 ../../without-stripped/program/libresourcemodello.so
1060956 ../../without-stripped/program/librptlo.so
1063280 ../../without-stripped/program/librptuilo.so
366516 ../../without-stripped/program/librptxmllo.so
310732 ../../without-stripped/program/librtftoklo.so
100208 ../../without-stripped/program/libsaxlo.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libsblo.so
42936 ../../without-stripped/program/libscdlo.so
2514892 ../../without-stripped/program/libscfiltlo.so
9930380 ../../without-stripped/program/libsclo.so
117064 ../../without-stripped/program/libscnlo.so
166100 ../../without-stripped/program/libscriptframe.so
655516 ../../without-stripped/program/libscuilo.so
63284 ../../without-stripped/program/libsdbc2.so
96248 ../../without-stripped/program/libsdbtlo.so
42984 ../../without-stripped/program/libsddlo.so
577748 ../../without-stripped/program/libsdfiltlo.so
5649156 ../../without-stripped/program/libsdlo.so
479504 ../../without-stripped/program/libsduilo.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libsfxlo.so
38808 ../../without-stripped/program/libsmdlo.so
170968 ../../without-stripped/program/libsmime3.so
932176 ../../without-stripped/program/libsmlo.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libsofficeapp.so
244204 ../../without-stripped/program/libsoftokn3.so
51048 ../../without-stripped/program/libsolverlo.so
344100 ../../without-stripped/program/libsotlo.so
232144 ../../without-stripped/program/libspalo.so
384532 ../../without-stripped/program/libspelllo.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libspllo.so
18128 ../../without-stripped/program/libspl_unxlo.so
483708 ../../without-stripped/program/libsqlite3.so
120564 ../../without-stripped/program/libsrtrs1.so
215892 ../../without-stripped/program/libssl3.so
699648 ../../without-stripped/program/libsvgfilterlo.so
962704 ../../without-stripped/program/libsvllo.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libsvtlo.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libsvxcorelo.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libsvxlo.so
55316 ../../without-stripped/program/libswdlo.so
11961644 ../../without-stripped/program/libswlo.so
2169716 ../../without-stripped/program/libswuilo.so
113248 ../../without-stripped/program/libt602filterlo.so
230732 ../../without-stripped/program/libtextconv_dict.so
104564 ../../without-stripped/program/libtextconversiondlgslo.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libtklo.so
567868 ../../without-stripped/program/libtllo.so
218928 ../../without-stripped/program/libtvhlp1.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libucb1.so
419912 ../../without-stripped/program/libucbhelper4gcc3.so
313468 ../../without-stripped/program/libucpchelp1.so
338460 ../../without-stripped/program/libucpdav1.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libucpfile1.so
170020 ../../without-stripped/program/libucpftp1.so
219144 ../../without-stripped/program/libucphier1.so
178168 ../../without-stripped/program/libucppkg1.so
120968 ../../without-stripped/program/libunopkgapp.so
158036 ../../without-stripped/program/libunordflo.so
441612 ../../without-stripped/program/libunoxmllo.so
59380 ../../without-stripped/program/libupdatecheckuilo.so
993664 ../../without-stripped/program/libutllo.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libuuilo.so
605420 ../../without-stripped/program/libvbahelperlo.so
4615288 ../../without-stripped/program/libvcllo.so
512592 ../../without-stripped/program/libvclplug_genlo.so
491884 ../../without-stripped/program/libvclplug_gtk3lo.so
467124 ../../without-stripped/program/libvclplug_gtklo.so
80152 ../../without-stripped/program/libvclplug_kde4lo.so
71796 ../../without-stripped/program/libvclplug_kdelo.so
92300 ../../without-stripped/program/libvclplug_svplo.so
764936 ../../without-stripped/program/libvisioimportlo.so
1179500 ../../without-stripped/program/libwpftlo.so
1056512 ../../without-stripped/program/libwpgimportlo.so
71680 ../../without-stripped/program/libwriterfilterlo.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libxcrlo.so
51000 ../../without-stripped/program/libxmlfalo.so
34544 ../../without-stripped/program/libxmlfdlo.so
273272 ../../without-stripped/program/libxmlsecurity.so
325708 ../../without-stripped/program/libxoflo.so
0 ../../without-stripped/program/libxolo.so
116888 ../../without-stripped/program/libxpcom_compat.so
779308 ../../without-stripped/program/libxpcom_core.so
13836 ../../without-stripped/program/libxpcom.so
129212 ../../without-stripped/program/libxsec_fw.so
695820 ../../without-stripped/program/libxsec_xmlsec.so
252472 ../../without-stripped/program/libxsltdlglo.so
100492 ../../without-stripped/program/libxsltfilterlo.so
489700 ../../without-stripped/program/libxstor.so
30360 ../../without-stripped/program/localebe1.uno.so
55264 ../../without-stripped/program/migrationoo2.uno.so
46984 ../../without-stripped/program/migrationoo3.uno.so
334636 ../../without-stripped/program/msforms.uno.so
30448 ../../without-stripped/program/mtfrenderer.uno.so
126240 ../../without-stripped/program/OGLTrans.uno.so
100268 ../../without-stripped/program/passwordcontainer.uno.so
679700 ../../without-stripped/program/postgresql-sdbc-impl.uno.so
50908 ../../without-stripped/program/postgresql-sdbc.uno.so
22272 ../../without-stripped/program/pythonloader.uno.so
5416 ../../without-stripped/program/pyuno.so
50996 ../../without-stripped/program/simplecanvas.uno.so
1363276 ../../without-stripped/program/slideshow.uno.so
133144 ../../without-stripped/program/stringresource.uno.so
34536 ../../without-stripped/program/syssh.uno.so
112628 ../../without-stripped/program/ucpcmis1.uno.so
26308 ../../without-stripped/program/ucpexpand1.uno.so
75648 ../../without-stripped/program/ucpext.uno.so
120880 ../../without-stripped/program/ucpgvfs1.uno.so
256372 ../../without-stripped/program/ucptdoc1.uno.so
63332 ../../without-stripped/program/updatefeed.uno.so
104516 ../../without-stripped/program/vbaevents.uno.so
1718712 ../../without-stripped/program/vbaobj.uno.so
1213864 ../../without-stripped/program/vbaswobj.uno.so
536072 ../../without-stripped/program/vclcanvas.uno.so
171373684 total
_______________________________________________
LibreOffice mailing list
LibreOffice@lists.freedesktop.org
http://lists.freedesktop.org/mailman/listinfo/libreoffice
