Comment #4 on issue 2460 by [email protected]: StaffGroup barlines should be whited-out to allow better Lyrics and Dynamics placement
http://code.google.com/p/lilypond/issues/detail?id=2460

I generally agree that vocal scores shouldn't have barlines across the whole StaffGroup. However, i see two possible cases when they might be acceptable:
- when someone wants to reproduce an old score which uses this
- in full score for conductor: barlines spanning whole ChoirStaff can improve the visual separation of the group from other groups. This would be especially helpful in a multi-chorus score: imagine a piece for 2 SATB choirs and 6 soloists in two gropus (and no instruments). Without staffGroup barlines it would be hard to distinguish the vocal groups from themselves.


Reply via email to