Comment #2 on issue 2718 by [email protected]: MusicXML regtest fails
http://code.google.com/p/lilypond/issues/detail?id=2718

Hmm. Been trying to make sense of what these XML files do and failing. See images of a couple of these - these were created by importing the XML into Sibelius (spit) and seem a reasonable attempt at creating music from the XML. I wouldn't write music like either of these: in bar 7 of 45e, where do you go back to? And what counts as a first time bar in that case? In 45d, what happened to the 4th time through? And where does the 3rd time section end? And where do you return from the 11th bar?

I'd like to write these to make more musical sense...

Attachments:
        45d-Repeats-Nested-Alternatives.xml.png  1.3 KB
        45e-Repeats-Nested-Alternatives.xml.png  1.2 KB


Reply via email to