On Sat, Dec 26, 2009 at 08:23:42PM +0100, Francisco Vila wrote: > 2009/12/26 Valentin Villenave <[email protected]>: > > 2009/12/26 John Mandereau <[email protected]>: > >>> Should we ask the -user-fr > >>> people to accept a name change to lilypond-fr ? > >> > >> This is perfectly acceptable, and I think a confirmation of Valentin, > >> the other administrator, will be enough to decide to request it to > >> Savannah hackers. If this happens, we should send a big fat warning on > >> the list and info-lilypond, and put a news item on lilypond.org, to > >> announce the name change. > > > > No problem as far as I'm concerned. That being said, I kinda like > > -user-fr, since it makes clear that this is an user-oriented list > > (most developers can handle enough English to use -devel anyway).
That's a good point. I mean, if somebody submits a bug report to the es list, presumably somebody would translate it and send it to the bug-lilypond list. > I should be more comfortable having lilypond-es and lilypond-user-fr > than forcing a rename of the fr list. I am also willing to go on with > lilypond-user-es if regularity over names is so much important, but > probably -utilisateurs or -fr alone would have been better from the > begninning. I other words, I do not want to impose my name scheme to > anyone, and I feel that a rename of an existing list is always a pain. I agree with almost everything you said -- a rename would be a bit of a pain, and it would have been nice if the fr list was just -fr from the beginning. However, I'm _not_ comfortable with lilypond-es and lilypond-user-fr; I'd like a consistent naming scheme. > Waiting for any directions on what to do from my side. The only thing we're waiting for is a definite decision about the name. In most cases when this happens, I'll just declare a definite decision and see if anybody objects, but since this is about translations I don't want to do this. John, please decide to go with lilypond-user-es. Once you've decided that, I'll make the list, and this task will be done. Cheers, - Graham _______________________________________________ lilypond-devel mailing list [email protected] http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-devel
