Kira,

Your computer will care. Some operating systems "register" installed applications to open certain kinds of files (or files with specific extensions; e.g., Adobe Acrobat is registered to open files with .pdf extensions so that one can double-click on the file in the File Explorer and the application will run and open the file).

By default Lilypond opens files with the .ly extension. When you install Frescobaldi there is usually a step where the installer specifically asks if you want it to open .ly files.

Having more than one version of a program installed requires that *you* keep track of which versions are registered and also where they are installed. For example, if Version X of ProgramA is installed and you then install Version Y, typically the installers are written to install files into the same path/folder. Thus Version Y will overwrite Version X. To prevent that, many installers give you the option to explicitly say where to install the application. That's what you'll have to do here.

It is possible to do this with both Lilypond and Frescobaldi. If I may, choose installation folders that have names relevant to your use for them. For example, since "work" requires LP 2.16.2, create a folder in your Home directory ~/<home>/Work/Programs and install LP 2.16.2 and an appropriate version of Frescobaldi (one that "knows" about LP 2.16.2 rather than LP 2.20.*) there. Then you can install the latest and greatest LP and Frescobaldi in their default locations. Updates to Frescobaldi and LP go to their defaults as they are released and the World folder remains constant and unaffected by those changes.

Many years ago I was the support triage agent for my IT group at a large mid-western public university. I had 3-4 different versions of MS Office, Corel Office, Adobe (everything) on the same computer (because there was no IT standardization across the university that that's what it took to support the many possible versions). It worked with due diligence (but no one, ever, was allowed to touch that computer LOL).

Hope I've helped a little.

Regards.

On Sat, Oct 23, 2021, 5:58 PM Kira Garvie <kgar...@gmail.com <mailto:kgar...@gmail.com>> wrote:

   What I was told is that there are some features on the back-end of
   the program that turns the Lilypond scores into manipulatable scores
   for the company that doesn't play well with some of the newer
   updates to Lilypond. So I can have more than one Lilypond program
   downloaded, my computer won't care?

   On Sat, Oct 23, 2021 at 6:50 PM David Kastrup <d...@gnu.org
   <mailto:d...@gnu.org>> wrote:

       Kira Garvie <kgar...@gmail.com <mailto:kgar...@gmail.com>> writes:

        > Hi all,
        > I saw this referenced in the Frescobaldi manual, but is it
       possible to have
        > multiple versions of Lilypond installed on my computer at
       once? Many of you
        > know I have to use version 2.16.2 for my work (don't ask me
       why, I honestly
        > don't know),

       That's more than 8 years old.  Does _anybody_ actually know?

        > but I would like to use a more recent version for some other
       engraving
        > jobs. And can I use an older version of Frescobaldi with a newer
        > version of Lilypond?  Thank you!  Best, Kira

       As far as I understand, Frescobaldi supported using multiple
       versions of
       LilyPond for a long time now.  Of course, an older version of
       Frescobaldi will not know about newer syntax features (like
       pitchless
       music for percussion entry and a number of other things).

-- David Kastrup

Reply via email to