What would be the correct way to engrave this? Space the 4 16ths evenly, put the two 8ths above their corresponding 16ths and squeezing the appoggiatura notes in? What if there's not enough place left for them - should the 16ths then be spaced further apart (evenly) until it fits? Even if this leads to the 16ths on beat 4 being spaced further apart than those on beat 3?

Basically, this is what happens with strict-grace-spacing = ##t:

With the unfortunate flaw that it does _not_ achieve the thing about "spacing the 16ths further apart if the grace notes take up too much space":

\version "2.22"

\layout {
  \override Score.SpacingSpanner.strict-grace-spacing = ##t
}

<<
  \new Staff \relative c'' {
    a16[ g b a] g8[ \appoggiatura { g32 a g a g a } b8]
  }
  \new Staff \relative c'' {
    a16[ g b a] e16[ d f e]
  }
>>

There's definitely room for improvement in cases such as these. But also here one should ask first: What would be the "correct" appearance? That's not clear to me at all.

Lukas


Reply via email to