Dear everybody,
So I've been wondering about the distance between the barline and the
first note of a measure.
I'm not an expert typesetter by any means, but it does seem to me that
the gap is narrower in lilypond scores than in examples by Gould, for
instance. I've come up with this comparison:
The example on the left is from a chorale I've made (attached.) The
Gould example is from page 468 of the 2011 edition.
The ratios of staff height to gap is 3.648 in lilypond, but 2.518 in
Gould. That means the lilypond gap is ~0,69% of the Gould gap, close to ⅔.
That's quite the difference.
Have I done something that diminishes the gap? (see attached chorale.ly)
Is the smaller gap by design? And if so, would it preferable to have it
bigger by default?
Can the gap be extended by some ratio of global staff size? (I'm
assuming a fixed increase would make problems with scores with a larger
basic staff size, like my own.)
I would appreciate any insight on the matter, both with regards to
desirable typesetting, my attached example, and how lilypond deals with
this. (I have yet to figure out how to read the detailed documentations
of engravers etc.)
Best wishes,
Jakob
Aarhus, Denmark
\version "2.25.6"
\language "deutsch"
\header {
title = "10. Alle mine kilder skal være hos dig"
composer = \markup { \vspace #1.5 \small { Thomas Laub 1922 } }
poet = \markup { \italic \small { Uregelmæssig tekst } }
}
\paper {
#(set-paper-size "a4landscape")
markup-system-spacing.basic-distance = #20
}
#(set-global-staff-size 24)
global = {
\key c \major
\time 4/2
}
alleminelinjeet = \lyricmode { \override LyricText.font-size = #-2
Al -- le mi -- ne kil -- der skal væ -- re hos "dig! /"
}
alleminerightOne = \relative c' {
\global
c4 c g' g a2 c4 c | h2 g4 g e1 |
}
alleminerightTwo = \relative c' {
\global
g4 g d' d c2 e4 e | e2 e4 d c1 |
}
allemineleftOne = \relative c {
\global
e4 e d d e2 a4 a | g a h h c1 |
}
allemineleftTwo = \relative c {
\global \voiceTwo
c4 c h h a2 a4 a | e'2 e4 g a1 |
}
\score {
\new PianoStaff <<
\new Lyrics = "alleminemelodi" \with {
\override VerticalAxisGroup.staff-affinity = #DOWN
}
\new Staff = "højre" <<
\new Voice = "sopran" {
\voiceOne
<< \alleminerightOne >>
}
\new Voice = "alt" {
\voiceTwo
<< \alleminerightTwo >>
}
>>
\new Staff = "venstre" <<
\clef bass
\new Voice = "tenor" {
\voiceOne
<< \allemineleftOne >>
}
\new Voice = "basses" {
\voiceTwo << \allemineleftTwo >>
}
>>
\context Lyrics = "alleminemelodi" \lyricsto "sopran" \alleminelinjeet
>>
\layout {
indent = 0.0
\context {
\Score \remove "Bar_number_engraver"
}
}
}
\markup { \vspace #1 \fill-line { \column { \line {} }
\right-column { \line { \abs-fontsize #12 {
\bold v6 \italic { Alle mine kilder skal være hos dig! }
} } \line { \abs-fontsize #12 {
\italic { Af dig genfødes skal jord og himmel } } } } }
}