Hi Kyle,

> Here's a (slightly more concise) MWE that works with everything... except for 
> if the MMRest starts on the first bar. Any help with that or feedback would 
> be greatly appreciated. Thank you again for everyone's help so far.

This is impressive!

That being said, if my 20+ years with Lilypond has taught me anything, it’s 
that this kind of solution likely isn’t necessary. I am 99% certain there’s a 
very simple incantation (maybe involving rods-and-springs or some other spacing 
parameter?) that will solve the problem with far less code. Consider how 
dynamics already Do The Right Thing™ w.r.t. vertical “slipping”:

%%%  EXAMPLE BEGINS
\version "2.25.1"
\language "english"
\paper { indent = 0 }

\new PianoStaff \with {
  \override StaffGrouper.staff-staff-spacing.padding = #0.2
  \override DynamicLineSpanner.staff-padding = #1.5
} <<
  \new Staff \relative c'' {
    \key c\minor \tempo"Tempo I" \stemUp
    <g d bf g>4\fp ~ <g d bf g>16. <g d>32-3 <a fs d>16.-4 <bf d,>32-5 <bf-5 g 
e>4( <a-4 fs>8) r | \noBreak
    <c-3 a fs>4\fp~<c a fs>16. <c a fs>32-4 <d a fs>16.-5 <ef a, fs>32-4 <ef-5 
a, fs>4( <d-5 bf g>8) r -\tweak color blue -\tweak Y-offset #-3.2 \p | \noBreak
    <c^5 a^3 fs^2>4\fp~<c a fs>16. <c a fs>32-3 <d a fs>16.-4 <ds a fs>32-5 <ds 
a fs>4-4^(\p <e g, e> | \noBreak
    <a,^5 fs^3 ds^2>\cresc
    \override Fingering.text = "4-5"
    <g e b>-4  <fs ds c a>-4\!
    \revert Fingering.text
    <ds-4 a fs>)\fermata \pp |
  }
  \new Staff \relative c {
    \clef bass\key c\minor
    \override Fingering.staff-padding = ##f
    <g d bf g>4~ <g d bf g>16. bf'32_2 a16. g32_5 cs4( d8) r16. ef,32 |
    ef'4~ ef16. ef32-2 d16.-1 c32 bf4. r16. ef,32 |
    ef'4 ~ ef16. ef32-2 d16.-1 c32-3 c8-2( b4-3) b8-1~ |
    b b,4_5 b_1 b,-5 b8-4_\fermata
    \bar"||"
  }
>>
%%%  EXAMPLE ENDS

I’m hoping to hear from Jean or David or someone with a deeper understanding of 
Lilypond than I have.

Best,
Kieren.
__________________________________________________

My work day may look different than your work day. Please do not feel obligated 
to read or respond to this email outside of your normal working hours.


Reply via email to