Hi Kieren,

> Do you know Jan-Peter’s Edition Engraver? If so: How does this compare to 
that,
> from an “under the hood” technical perspective? One issue with the EE is that
> you can’t attach events at any moment where there isn’t a pre-existing event,
> but your pp at (6 1/2) suggests that your mechanism does not suffer that 
issue.

I don’t really know the edition engraver. I just never really got warm with the 
syntax. I generally stopped really at having to assign ids to contexts and 
stuff. But yes, this does not require time steps to be already scheduled.

> I’m very interested in something more lightweight than the full EE being
> available to people in “vanilla Lilypond”, and this looks like a strong
> candidate, especially if we can supply some “sugar” so the UI/UX is as
> user-friendly as Jan-Peter’s.

No. If we were specifically talking vanilla Lilypond I would much rather solve 
this from a music iterator viewpoint:

Have a music iterator that does not simply iterate sequentially or something, 
but that iterates by measure positions. Of course, such music types kind of 
have weird implications on music length and such. But having to do this from 
the engraver side comes with severe limitations and headaches.

I would much rather have a music type, maybe even with some specific syntax 
such as

<<<
  3:1/4:0 => ...
  6:0:0 => ...
>>>

to inject music at specific times. This would essentially turn edition engraver 
into a quite simple music function.

Cheers,
Tina

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part.

Reply via email to