Dear list, I engrave Anglican chant and plainchant, and I keep running into the same spacing problem with reciting notes. I attach a small example (.ly and PDF).
*Background.* In chant, many words are sung on one pitch, the reciting
note. The convention in my choir is to print a single whole-note head where
the recitation begins. That head is only a signal (“the recitation starts
here, on this pitch”); it says nothing about duration. The remaining
syllables of the recitation are printed with no note heads above them.
*My current approach.* I enter the reciting note as a whole note glyph with
reduced duration (1*1/4) followed by one quarter note per remaining
LyricText item sung to the reciting note. Then I make all the note heads
after the first one in the recitation vanish (score 2 in the attachment).
Kudos to Lukas, who wrote \vanish and \unvanish. The \vanish command is
deliberately more thorough than the attached small example needs, so that
it can cover all anticipated use cases. The command combines the
definitions of NullVoice and \hideNotes (using \omit instead of \hide), so
that vanished notes of any kind are omitted entirely and cannot affect
spacing.
*The problem.* LilyPond still spaces the whole note like a conventional
note from metrical music, with a rhythmic duration, so the second word of a
recitation is sometimes pushed to the right, away from the first word. (See
“I will” and “I have” in score 2.) I would like *the words of a recitation
to be spaced like running text*, with the whole-note head simply sitting
above the first word. Score 3 shows the word spacing that I want, but it is
very hack-y and not a general solution. I only got it by narrowing
line-width, which will not work across a whole psalm.
*What I have tried:*
- \tweak NoteHead.X-extent #empty-interval on the whole note: The gap
goes away, but the first word is no longer centred under the head. Also,
unisons look wrong (the desired two note heads collapse into one). In
Anglican chant, two voices share a staff and are sometimes in unison on the
reciting note, so two whole-note heads must print side by side; with an
empty X-extent they no longer do. (The attached example has only one
voice, to keep it small, but a solution needs to work for these
soprano-alto unisons too.)
- Combining multiple words into one LyricText object (e.g., \markup { I
will praise God, be } --): This does not work because then LilyPond
cannot do line breaks during that item/object.
*What I need:*
1. The whole-note head *keeps its real width* for note collisions
(unison heads side by side) and for aligning the first LyricText item.
2. The head, or pair of heads, *adds nothing to the distance to the
next LyricText object*. When the first word of the recitation is very
short (e.g., “a” or “I”), the next word should be free to sit partly
beneath the whole-note head(s), since nothing is printed on the staff above
it.
*Is there a property or callback that would help me get what I need?*
Cheers,
Gabriel
Reciting note first lyric - MWE - v3.ly
Description: Binary data
Reciting note first lyric - MWE - v3.pdf
Description: Adobe PDF document
