On 09/10/2026 16:48, Yoshiaki Onishi wrote:
Dear Timwi,
I’m overriding the hshift specifically to put it on the left. (I’m transcribing
music from a scanned manuscript and I would like to replicate the original,
which has the dotted half note (including its dot) to the left of the whole
note.)
How about the following?
%%%BEGIN%%%
\version "2.24.0"
hn = { \once \override NoteColumn.force-hshift = 0 }
hr = { \once \override NoteColumn.force-hshift = 0.25 }
\score {
<<
\new Staff {
<<
\new Voice {
\voiceTwo
\hr a'1
}
\new Voice {
\voiceFour
a'2.
}
>>
}
>>
}
%%%END%%%
The voice layer management may become tricky when typesetting a longer example,
but if you are looking for a temporary relief of some sorts, it seems the above
code fulfills your wish.
Thank you! Based on your suggestion, I took a bit of a deep-dive into
what \voice[One/Two/Three/Four] do internally to understand why your fix
works. These commands are shorthand for setting 17 properties to up/down
(plus 14 more just for grace notes, plus NoteColumn.horizontal-shift),
ranging from slurs and ties over tuplet brackets to trill spanners. It
even includes DotColumn and Dots.
Nevertheless, it turns out the only property that influences what I’m
after (the position of the dot), is the *stem* direction.
Therefore, in my particular case, I can work around the problem by using
\once \override Stem.direction = #DOWN ... but this only works because
the affected note happens to be a whole note that doesn’t have a visible
stem. If it were a half note, this solution wouldn’t be adequate.
I’ll assume, therefore, that there is no known way to manually place the
dot. :(
Thanks for your help though!
Timwi