Dear List,I hope you are well. Sorry in advance for the length of the email here, though the overarching topic here is Woodwind Diagrams (https://lilypond.org/doc/v2.26/Documentation/notation/woodwinds.html#woodwind-diagrams).
About a year ago, I posted the following Work Items on GitLab. These refer to some bugs and defects I had discovered when using 'low-bass-clarinet fingering diagram on LilyPond:
https://gitlab.com/lilypond/lilypond/-/work_items/6840 https://gitlab.com/lilypond/lilypond/-/work_items/6841A year later, I am more comfortable in looking at Scheme code, and as a clarinetist myself, I wanted to address the matters described in these two Work Items.
In the attachment:* As Fingering Diagrams 5 and 6 show, I have revamped the the design of low-c, low-cis, and low-d (which now shows up) buttons, and I brought them down to where you would usually see in other publications. The new shape was inspired by both Buffet and Selmer bass clarinets.
* I also made sure that left-hand D appears for 'low-bass-clarinet.
* r.h. one through four keys are fixed; they will not move whether or
not the left hand pinky keys as well as low-c, -cis, and -d keys are
present.
* (_Enhancement not described in the two Work Items_) There is now a
new key, provisionally called l.h. "aes" that you can see between l.h. e
and fis keys. Diagram 2 shows it activated. This is an auxiliary key,
very commonly found in intermediate-to-professional clarinets of today.
* (_Enhancement_) I have redesigned l.h. cis key. Somehow the current
design didn't seem right with me, because it is a key that you would use
a pinky finger to activate, and that it was right next to "cc three"
seemed a bit off.
* (_Enhancement_) I resized and adjusted the placement of l.h. f. I
made it smaller so it looks balanced with l.h. cis and, for
'low-bass-clarinet, d key(s).
Before I clean up and submit the two .scm files (in the depth of LilyPond!) to the Dev Team on GitLab, I wanted to share the attached PDF file. At this moment, I would be grateful if you could take a look at the design of it all. I plan to send this to clarinet-playing colleagues and friends and get their feedback, as well.
Thanks everyone! YoshiP.S. By the way, 'low-bass-clarinet hasn't been documented, for which I made another work item (https://gitlab.com/lilypond/lilypond/-/work_items/6842)
-- Yoshiaki Onishi https://github.com/yoshiakionishi/lilypond-snippets
fingering_test.pdf
Description: Adobe PDF document
