Paul Crabbe <[email protected]> writes:

> Hello to all, I'm new to the list.
>
> When using temporary polyphony syntax, in a \relative notation
> context, I stumble on a recurring problem : changing one note height
> in one voice will affect octave positionnig on other voice :
>
> %========================================================================
>
> \relative c'' {
>     <<
>       {c e c g}\\
>       {c, c c c}
>     >>
> }
>
> % changing last note on \voice 1 will move \voice 2 one octave up : 
> \relative c'' {
>     <<
>       {c e c g'}\\
>       {c, c c c}
>     >>
> }

Why wouldn't it?

The propagation rules of \relative are basically:
{ ... } the last pitch in the set propagates as the reference outside
<< ... >> the last pitch in the set propagates as the reference outside
< ... > the first pitch in the set propagates as the reference outside

Apparently you are imagining yet another scheme

<< ... >> no propagation of relative pitch happens inside, every element
inside starts with the outside reference pitch which presumably is also
what gets passed outside unmodified at the end.

Would be an idea, but that ship has sailed.  Too much historic baggage.

-- 
David Kastrup


Reply via email to