Werner LEMBERG <[email protected]> writes:

>>> I should have actually asked for examples where time signatures in
>>> one staff share the same horizontal space with key signatures in
>>> another staff.  As it turns out, the problem affects only pieces
>>> with two staves per system:
>>> https://gitlab.com/lilypond/lilypond/-/merge_requests/3224
>> 
>> Sigh.  No, it doesn't.  [...]
>
> Sloppy wording on my side, sorry.  This remark was not targeting
> LilyPond's algorithm but rather how it is done in published music.
>
>>> As soon as there are more staves involved, it's rather clear that
>>> time signatures must always come after key signatures so that they
>>> can be properly aligned vertically in the score.
>> 
>> Reminds me of the simple rule to figure out where a mathematical
>> proof goes wrong.  Just look for the first occurence of a phrase
>> like "it is rather clear", "obviously" or similar.
>
> The same.  Not related to the algorithm but how music typesetters
> print scores.

So you did find a relevant example?  Can we see it?

-- 
David Kastrup

Reply via email to