This works perfectly for me. Attached is a diff with minor syntax
changes to "\set stanza" for 2.27.2. There's also a block comment for
the test harness. It can then just be \include'd into my score.
Wonderful.
I do however have a personal sense of unease. I once came to rely on
another block of Scheme that I barely understood (another example of
"cargo-cult" coding). I couldn't keep it updated for syntax/API
changes in lilypond, and for over a year that effectively locked me out
of all the scores that used it. It would be wonderful if someone™ with
actual skills could merge this functionality into lilypond itself.
On Sun, 2026-11-15 at 15:20 +0000, Graham King wrote:
> Well, this list is usually prompt, polite and helpful but, Gabriel,
> you have just set a new record for the response time! You have just
> posted an answer to the very question for which I was in the middle
> of composing an MWE. I'll test your example later today.
>
> Thanks!
> -- Graham
diff --git a/Carry_Mark_in_Lyrics_v5.ily b/Carry_Mark_in_Lyrics_v5.ily
index 82cb8ee..d40ff20 100644
--- a/Carry_Mark_in_Lyrics_v5.ily
+++ b/Carry_Mark_in_Lyrics_v5.ily
@@ -238,6 +238,7 @@ withLyricTieHarm = \with {
DOWN))))
}
+%{ % Comment out the test harness...
%%% TEST 1: MWE from “O sacrum convivium” (Thomas Tallis); beginning
%%% of the motet in the Discantus part, transposed up a whole step
@@ -263,10 +264,10 @@ text = \lyricmode {
\new Voice = "discantus" \discantus
\new Lyrics
\with \withLyricTieClaude
- \lyricsto "discantus" { \set stanza = "Claude:" \text }
+ \lyricsto "discantus" { \stanza "Claude:" \text }
\new Lyrics
\with \withLyricTieHarm
- \lyricsto "discantus" { \set stanza = "Harm:" \text }
+ \lyricsto "discantus" { \stanza "Harm:" \text }
>>
\header { piece = "Test 1: Tallis, “O sacrum convivium” (Discantus, opening)" }
}
@@ -308,10 +309,10 @@ testText = \lyricmode {
\new Voice = "test" \testMelody
\new Lyrics
\with \withLyricTieClaude
- \lyricsto "test" { \set stanza = "Claude:" \testText }
+ \lyricsto "test" { \stanza "Claude:" \testText }
\new Lyrics
\with \withLyricTieHarm
- \lyricsto "test" { \set stanza = "Harm:" \testText }
+ \lyricsto "test" { \stanza "Harm:" \testText }
>>
\layout { ragged-right = ##t }
\header { piece = "Test 2: whole words of different lengths, each on one note" }
@@ -346,6 +347,8 @@ depthMelody = \relative c'' {
depthText = \lyricmode {
Lord, \startTextSpan are \stopTextSpan
+ \once \override TextSpanner.details.left-overlap = #-0.2
+ \once \override TextSpanner.details.right-overlap = #0
Lord, \startTextSpan are \stopTextSpan
Lord, \startTextSpan are \stopTextSpan
}
@@ -355,12 +358,12 @@ depthText = \lyricmode {
\new Voice = "depth" \depthMelody
\new Lyrics
\with \withLyricTieClaude
- \lyricsto "depth" { \set stanza = "Claude:" \depthText }
+ \lyricsto "depth" { \stanza "Claude:" \depthText }
\new Lyrics
\with \withLyricTieClaude
% Try different values here (staff spaces):
\with { \override TextSpanner.details.tie-height = 0.5 }
- \lyricsto "depth" { \set stanza = "Fixed depth:" \depthText }
+ \lyricsto "depth" { \stanza "Fixed depth:" \depthText }
>>
\layout { ragged-right = ##t }
\header { piece = "Test 3: Claude’s approach, with and without a fixed tie depth" }
@@ -406,13 +409,13 @@ splitTextTweaked = \lyricmode {
\new Voice = "split" \splitMelody
\new Lyrics
\with \withLyricTieClaude
- \lyricsto "split" { \set stanza = "Claude:" \splitText }
+ \lyricsto "split" { \stanza "Claude:" \splitText }
\new Lyrics
\with \withLyricTieClaude
- \lyricsto "split" { \set stanza = "Tweaked:" \splitTextTweaked }
+ \lyricsto "split" { \stanza "Tweaked:" \splitTextTweaked }
\new Lyrics
\with \withLyricTieHarm
- \lyricsto "split" { \set stanza = "Harm:" \splitText }
+ \lyricsto "split" { \stanza "Harm:" \splitText }
>>
\layout { ragged-right = ##t }
\header { piece = "Test 4: a carry mark split by a line break" }
@@ -448,11 +451,13 @@ markupText = \lyricmode {
\new Voice = "markup" \markupMelody
\new Lyrics
\with \withLyricTieClaude
- \lyricsto "markup" { \set stanza = "Claude:" \markupText }
+ \lyricsto "markup" { \stanza "Claude:" \markupText }
\new Lyrics
\with \withLyricTieHarm
- \lyricsto "markup" { \set stanza = "Harm:" \markupText }
+ \lyricsto "markup" { \stanza "Harm:" \markupText }
>>
\layout { ragged-right = ##t }
\header { piece = "Test 5: no punctuation, and syllables written with markup" }
}
+
+%}
\ No newline at end of file