2011/1/23 Xavier Scheuer <[email protected]>: > On 23 January 2011 23:09, Joseph Haig <[email protected]> wrote: >> { >> \time 4/4 >> aes'1( a') >> aes'~ aes' >> aes'( aes') >> } >> >> I believe that the first and third ties are displayed incorrectly. >> Specifically, the first tie should have a natural in front of the >> second note, > > Nope. > Usual rules specify that an accidental is only valid within _one_ > (the current) measure[1]. The second a') (in the second measure) is not > in the same measure, so no need to print the natural.
I don't agree. *Theoretically* accidental is not needed, but if it would be omitted, how can you tell the difference between aes~ | aes and aes( | a) ? In my opinion accidental here is necessary (surely it may be parenthesized). If it's necessary, it should be printed automatically in my opinion. cheers, Janek _______________________________________________ lilypond-user mailing list [email protected] http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-user
