PMA <PeterArmstrong <at> aya.yale.edu> writes: > Keith OHara wrote: > > > > Maybe by default LilyPond could break the ties based on staff-position, > > Might \naturalizeMusic specifically target Ambitus? >
I would think that the desired output is to show the versions that indicate the full range of staff-positions, rather than the versions with fewest accidentals, for practical use of the ambitus. That is, consider E-sharp lower than F, and G-sharp lower than A-flat (in the default case where LilyPond uses 12-equal divisions of the octave for the pitches, so that the pitches themselves are tied). (I do, in fact, agree that in any context where you would see E-sharp and F in the same piece, the E-sharp indicates the lower pitch, or at least the conceptually-lower pitch.) The actual request on the but tracker, on the other hand, suggests using the version that best-fits the key signature. (I suppose the first key signature in the piece, in case it changes.) _______________________________________________ lilypond-user mailing list [email protected] https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-user
