>I thought I understood how PAV works and it was my impression that the i/o
>subsystem knew the addresses belonged to a PAV and would/could drive
>simultaneous i/o to the phys device.  If so ... then the dasd driver would
>register a single disk with the block layer.

The DASD driver registers one disk for the base and one disk for each
alias.

> Which means that lvm1 would
>not know about the multiple PAV addresses used by the i/o subsys ... only
>seeing a single disk.

No, see above, it sees multiple addresses and recognizes
that they all belong to the same physical disk.

>However, coming in through scsi, with multiple
>interfaces out to the storage, you would indeed see multiple disks
>registered with the block layer ... all of them mapped to the same phys
>disk.  This is a situation in which I think you'd use lvm1 with its
support
>for multi-paths.

PAV exists only for ESCON or FICON, not SCSI.

>MD has also introduced multi-path support by adding an mp
>personality.  Its job is to aggregate the multi-path disks and present
them
>as a single md volume.

We prefer LVM for various reasons.
For more details, see my WAVV-presentation (www.linuxvm.org).

Klaus Bergmann

Reply via email to