> > You are not forced to define the private data members and functions at the > > same time as the public ones in C++. The way to handle this is to put the public > > interface in a pure virtual class: > > In my opinion (please note that this IS an opinion) the method you propose > is at least as ugly as any other way of keeping a class's private data members > private. IMO, using C and doing
I don't see what makes the method I propose, and that most C++ programmers use, ugly. It is much cleaner and explicit that your method below. > typedef void Object ; > > Object * Object_new (/* parameters */) ; You cannot create an Object on the stack. With C++ classes you can. This makes resource management much easier. > int method_1 (Object *object, /* parameters */) ; This is not type safe. I suppose this function method_1 then calls another function via a pointer stored somewhere in *object? > void Object_delete (void) ; void Object_delete(Objects *object); ? > and then using a struct (return a pointer to it from Object_new()) in the > implementation file is neater and works better. I think it is less flexible, less readable and error prone. > If you think C++ is great, then you are entitled to your opinion. In my > experience, the C++ boosters are far pushier with their form of religion > than the people who prefer C to C++. Hmm. I tend to think it's the other way round. (the standard "C++ is slow", "C++ isn't really OO", etc. arguments are quite often seen.) > > I think most of the arguments in the article are not valid, > > Most of the arguments or just the ones relating to C++? I did talk about > stuff other than C++ in that article. I meant only the ones related to C++. [...] > 2) OO can be done in Standard C. Sure. But the language does not support it, it merely enables its use. > 3) Some people (me included) might prefer doing OO programing in C > rather than C++. It is not up to me to tell you what language to use. As you in your article talked how you think C is a better language, I gave my point of view. --ms
