Comparing attempts to prevent a genocide with breaking the copyrights law is an insult to whomever been in the holocaust. You cannot dismiss any laws you do not agree with, it just doesn't work this way - YOU should get a reality check (and a shrink or a probation officer, ASAP.). It's not that disobeying this specific law will cause chaos, but the idea that an individual is obeying only the laws he agrees with will.
The music industry supplies work to the software engineering industry, hardware, catering, electricity, real estate, and many, many, MANY more, not to mention that a couple of other large industries, else than the music industry, rely on the copyrights laws. You are trying to justify your criminal actions with ethics, which is just wrong. But go ahead, share music and other copyrighted material if you want... I won't be sorry if and when they will rip you off everything you own in court. -- Imri Zvik PGP (2.6.3ia) Public Key: http://mariska.inter.net.il/~imriz/imriz.pgp -----Original Message----- From: Shlomi Fish [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, May 25, 2005 3:22 PM To: Imri Zvik Cc: [email protected] Subject: Re: Acting against anti-file-swapping Lawsuits in Israel On Wednesday 25 May 2005 14:45, Imri Zvik wrote: > When people start choosing what laws to obey and what not, it is the > fastest way to chaos. The only valid laws are the prevention of initiatory force, threat of force, or fraud against one's self or property (not the so-called "intellectual property"). All other laws: against drug abuse, against prostitution, against gambling, against insider's information, against monopolies etc. etc. are irrelevant and unethical. Violating a law that says that one should not share his music over the Internet, will not cause any chaos. People do it all the time, and still food is in supply, stores are open, water is flowing in the pipes, there's supply of electricity, and the Internet is available for commerce and recreation. You should get a reality check. > The fact is that you still break the laws of the > sovereign, democratic entity you're part of, and that would make you an > outlaw, a criminal. If I lived in Nazi Germany and hidden a Jew in my house, (which was against the law) would that make me a criminal? (please don't invoke Godwin's law here) Laws that are unethical, need not be followed. > And about the economic system - didn't you ever hear about the term "The > Domino Effect"? Music for example pays salaries of numerous of people, > allowing them to be able to buy other products and services, and by that > help other people receive a paycheck. Producing and trading copyrighted > materiel is still producing and trading, which is, as you stated, are > the foundation stones of our economic system. Saying that the fact you > can't smell/touch it makes it ok, is so... uhmm, idiotic? As far as I > know, you're not an ostrich, so don't burry your head in the sand. > Domino effect.. hmmm... according to this logic, if we lower the income tax, then firing a great deal of government bureaucrats will also cause the economy to collapse. ;-) If people download music instead of buying it, then the public as a whole will be more prosperous, and will spend this money or invest on better things. While we may kill the music industry (highly unlikely, but still) the other industries will be much better off. During the course of human history entire industries were superceded by other ones, and yet we still live to tell the tale, and we are better and more prosperous and more advanced than ever. Again, you're misapplying concepts. Regards, Shlomi Fish --------------------------------------------------------------------- Shlomi Fish [EMAIL PROTECTED] Homepage: http://www.shlomifish.org/ Tcl is LISP on drugs. Using strings instead of S-expressions for closures is Evil with one of those gigantic E's you can find at the beginning of paragraphs. ================================================================To unsubscribe, send mail to [EMAIL PROTECTED] with the word "unsubscribe" in the message body, e.g., run the command echo unsubscribe | mail [EMAIL PROTECTED]
