If you arg thinking of buying a new graphic card, and want to choose ati....
i wouldn't recommend that.


Although oficially ati has "catalyst" drivers for their new cards  - it
didn't work on mine (which is supported)


i have recently bought a new computer. my old one had nvidia , and my new
has ati 4550 passive.

on nvidia, as i recall. if i didn't have distribution specific drivers, i
could install the binary one.
picking it was easy. there was only one to pick from.
i installed it, and it worked.
on ubuntu, there was a distribuition speceific driver and it worked out of
the box

in ati - i had to choose from a list of around 20. neither had 4550 as an
option. i chose the one marked as 'X550'
i installed the driver, it didn't tell me if it was the right driver or not.
rebooting as they asked, and running X, i got a distorted screen with
horizontal lines on it.

i erased /etc/X11/xorg.conf, and tried installing the driver again. when i
ran "aticonfig --initial" it refused as i had no xorg.conf
i tried 'X -configure' (which worked before i installed the driver), but it
failed with sig 11.
and now i do not have X, to find how to uninstall it ...

it was good i had a backup of my xorg.conf (with the opensource driver)

ati gave a link to where to send bug reports. i followed the link just to
find a page full of information which didn't have any place to put a bug
report on.
after nevigating for some time i found where i can fill a bug report. but i
have to register first. i had to fill in many fields like what version of
their catalyst driver i was using (and of-course the version which i
downloaded the same day from their site wasn't there).
in the end i filed a bug report and went to bed.

A day later i got an email: just press this link and login, and you will
find an answer
i loged-in -> again many detailes, neither relevant.
i pressed the link again. this time one link was relevant - it was an answer
to my bug report and it was:
quoting: "Although we have drivers for Linux posted on the ATI website, we
do not provide technical support for driver or multimedia issues in Linux
directly. "

so i say again. i wouldn't recomend buying from ATI.
from now on. no ati neither amd for me.

(with nvidia i used twinview and tv-out. i hope the opensource  ati driver
supports this ...)


cheers,
erez.

Reply via email to