On Thu, Dec 27, 2001 at 02:57:34PM +0100, Petr Olivka wrote:
> Hi !
> 
>   I know, 6110 is not full irda compatible, but with kernel 2.2.17, when I
> "cat /dev/irlpt1" and print from 6110, I obtain data corretly.

Try the gnokii package.  http://www.gnokii.org/ i believe.

The fact that you got (what seemed) correct output from Linux IrCOMM in
2.2.17 is just a coincidence, because Nokia 6110 doesn't do IrDA as you
correctly state.  The fact that you don't get the same output from Linux
IrCOMM in 2.4.13 is good, this means that the Linux IrDA code in 2.4.13 is
of higher quality than the one in 2.2.17.

Some people might think that this is just lameass programmer bullshit,
coming from ignorant programmers that don't appreciate the ability to
actually use the software, rather than sit and look at it.  However, what is
important to remember is that it isn't supposed to be possible to use the
two softwares (6110 and Linux) in the way that you've done with 2.2.17 and
therefore there is no way of knowing how to make a software do so correctly,
without causing e.g. data loss (phonebook entries disappearing in the 6110,
harddisk gets wrecked by Linux, etc.) or other unwanted behaviour.  I don't
know for a fact that either of these things will happen, but I don't know
for a fact that they won't.  And I wouldn't take the risk.  Anything is
possible since there is no protocol or ruleset provided for communication
between 6110 and Linux.

The programmer wants to produce quality code, quality systems, things that
don't break, things that just work.  But it takes some time.  And when the
working things are all done, good user interfaces can be made without
hassle.  But that's another science all together.  :)


//Peter

-- 
irc: CareBear\
irl: Peter Stuge
_______________________________________________
Linux-IrDA mailing list  -  [EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://www.pasta.cs.UiT.No/mailman/listinfo/linux-irda

Reply via email to