hi ya charles

yes....  sometimes, if a master disk died... there was no slave...
on that ide controller... need to test for this case...

normally....
ide0 = hda + hdb 
ide1 = hdc + hdd

simple case...

primary   hda ( master on ide0 )
mirror    hdc ( master on ide1 )
        -- ie...dont use hdb .... use 2 ide cables...

        if you lose hda due to disk crash....
        data should still be intact on hdc...unless that data too
        has been already mirrored... and erased...

        - i dont like automated mirroring...cause it should erase data on
        the mirror too that you wanted to retreive...
        
        - daily or hourly mirrors are good... but not automated...
        ( my silly preference ... and nope...my preference changes
        ( for real-time apps )

or w/ striping

(primary)  md0 = hda + hdd ??  vs hda + hdc 
(mirror)   md1 = hdc + hdb ??  vs hdb + hdd

if you lose  the "master disk" (hda) of the primary data -- 
we all assume you can get it off the mirror ( hdc + hdb )...
but the big problem is the slave(hdb) might not be accessible
since hda is offline... ( bad ide controllers )

so the trick should be....
- slave ( hdb, hdd )  disks should be accessible even if there is nomaster...

different ide controllers behave differently...
        - test it thoroughly by powerdown the ide with hdparm
        and or pull the ide cable...

        - write fresh new data with each power up/down cycle
        
have fun
alvin

On Tue, 17 Apr 2001, C. R. Oldham wrote:

> > -- question is... if the "master" disk dies...sometimes
> >    the slave dont exist either... than you're sol...
> 
> But you probably don't want to put disks on both the master and slave
> channels anyway since it will limit your throughput--only one can be
> accessed at any one time.
> 
> -- 
>   / C. R. (Charles) Oldham | NCA-CASI                     \
>  / Director of Technology  | Arizona State University      \
> / [EMAIL PROTECTED]          | V:480-965-8703  F:480-965-9423 \
> 

-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-raid" in
the body of a message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to