Hi Edward,
> > does somebody know a recent definite statement from xfs or reiserfs
> > developers(!), ...
> >
> > - that, concerning reiserfs, the problems that were in the past
> > (concerning buffering code treated differently between SW RAID and
> > reiserfs and maybe corrupting data in some cases) are definitely SOLVED
> > now or not ???
> Not if you meant sw raid5+reiserfs on 2.2.X.
> It is more kernel issue than reiserfs.
OK, so 2.2.X still has problems.
What about kernel >= 2.4.3 ?
> > Well, I�m NOT interested in "it seems to work" statements.
> >
> > I definitely believe that it is no problem doing an mkreiserfs or mkxfs
> > on /dev/md0 - BUT the trouble might not happen under normal operation,
> > but in case of failures (HDD failed, system crashed, raid resyncing and
> > reiserfs working in transaction log -> data corruption !?). The last
> > thing a RAID user wishes in such a critical situation is ADDITIONAL
> > trouble.
> >
> > So if you know of any posting, web site or documentation, stating that
> > the trouble is gone and that it should really work now, pleast post the
> > URL.
> >
> > Thanks,
> >
> > Thomas
-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-raid" in
the body of a message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
