I vote that we just leave the default choice to Jim. Then we can all blame him.
Well, I do like the MacOSX theme. I'll consider changing to that as the default ... so let's simplify things, and make it a straight head-to-head between Crao and MacOSX :-)
The key problem with comments in a wiki is that they are never removed.
:-) There is a philosophical split between comment-based wikis, and the page-edit style. I can't remember the jargon used, it was the sort of thing that the MeatBall Wiki is full of. [http://www.usemod.com/cgi-bin/mb.pl?MeatballWiki]
I prefer the page-edit style - it seems to be less likely to gunk up. The case of the DefaultTheme page is special - once the decision has been made, the Add Comment box will go away, and the comments will be 'archived' - and perhaps even the page will become unlinked.
Also, I get every change to the wiki emailed to me as it happens. If I don't like something (in as objective a manner as I can achieve) I'll remove it.
-jim
